Solar will get too cheap to connect to the power grid
Long-Distance Transmission & Grids
- One path for excess solar is exporting power via long-distance high-voltage transmission, as with China’s ultra-high-voltage lines and proposed Australia–Singapore cables.
- HVDC is argued to be sufficient (≈3.5% loss per 1,000 km, less than AC); superconductors seen as unnecessary and currently impractical (brittle, expensive).
- Continental grids could smooth solar across time zones (e.g., US east–west), but large grid expansions are seen as slow, expensive, politically fraught, and security-sensitive.
Desalination and Water from Excess Solar
- Many see solar-powered desalination as a prime “dump load”: deserts near coasts could gain water and new arable/usable land.
- Counterpoints: brine discharge can damage near-shore ecosystems; evidence of concentrated high-salinity plumes and long outflow pipes is cited.
- Others argue global impact is tiny versus natural evaporation, with effects mostly local and mitigable via dilution, mixing with treated sewage, or further processing.
- Capital cost, not energy, dominates desal economics; plants must run near-continuously. Using only midday surplus demands much cheaper plant construction.
Economics of Solar, Storage, and Incentives
- Debate over whether “too cheap” solar leads to underinvestment: some say negative or low midday prices will self-correct and curb new builds; others say once cheap enough, people buy for direct usefulness, not ROI.
- Excess solar can be monetized via arbitrage and flexible loads (batteries, fertilizer production, CO₂ capture, overcooling buildings, water).
- Battery round-trip efficiency is quoted around 80+%; there is confusion and dispute over how capacity factor and efficiency interact at grid scale.
Rooftop vs Utility-Scale Solar
- Utility-scale solar is broadly seen as much cheaper per MWh than rooftop.
- Rooftop is criticized as heavily subsidized via net metering, shifting costs to non-solar customers.
- Others counter that rooftop only needs to beat retail (not wholesale) prices and can already be rational, especially in high-tariff regions; soft costs and policy design (connection fees, export tariffs) are key.
Batteries, EVs, and Off-Grid Trends
- Home batteries are getting cheaper; some expect them to become widely affordable within 5–10 years.
- EVs with large batteries and vehicle-to-home/grid are viewed as emerging storage assets, especially as used EV prices fall.
- In places with unreliable grids (e.g., South Africa), solar + batteries are already widely used to reduce or eliminate grid dependence.
Environmental & Scale Concerns; Skepticism
- Some worry cheap solar will boost total energy use with unclear long-term effects, though others note solar’s lower climate impact vs fossil fuels despite lower albedo.
- There is skepticism about long-range projections that promise “effectively free” energy, likened to past “too cheap to meter” claims, and about the reliability of some official solar deployment statistics.