We're not going to run out of new anatomy anytime soon
DNA, Cell Context, and Developmental Information
- Multiple commenters question the idea that “it’s all encoded in DNA,” stressing:
- The zygote’s pre-existing structure, maternal environment, and epigenetic factors.
- Maternal-effect molecules (mRNA, proteins) in the egg affecting early development.
- Cell-level “navigation” guided by bioelectric fields or chemical gradients.
- Some argue you cannot “clean build” a human from DNA alone:
- Need an existing cell as “compiler” and maternal physiology as part of the “program.”
- DNA may describe transformations of existing cellular structures, not how to build them from scratch.
- Others compare DNA to compressed code, package manifests, or bindings to shared protein “libraries,” not a full blueprint.
Anatomical Knowledge Gaps and Incentives
- Surprise that essentially no one has a full-time job “just discovering anatomy.”
- Structural discovery is often a byproduct of surgery, imaging, or pathology, not a central goal.
- Funding and career incentives reward work that fits into existing frameworks, not “we found a weird new thing with unknown function.”
- Complaints that big-budget physics gets funding, while paleontology, anatomy, and fossil prep are chronically underfunded.
Bias, Neglected Regions, and Historical Oversights
- Several note prudishness/sexism and historical religious pressures as reasons for neglected female anatomy and reproductive structures.
- Examples: late appreciation of clitoral complexity, debate over the G-spot, reevaluation of “vestigial” organs like the appendix and thymus.
- Others caution that current perspectives are also biased; “bias” itself isn’t inherently bad but shapes what gets studied.
Variability and the Scale of the Problem
- Reports that major nerves (e.g., vagus) show extreme individual variability in branching and routing.
- Suggestion that gross anatomy is far from “finished” and clinical use requires detailed variation mapping across many individuals.
Tools, Imaging, and AI
- Suggestions that better tools, not just more surgeons/cadavers, are needed:
- High-resolution whole-body imaging datasets shared openly.
- Cheap, open ultrasound hardware and improved in vivo imaging.
- Knife-edge scanning microscopes and whole-organism 3D atlases.
- Hopes that AI could help integrate and interpret massive anatomical datasets, though details remain unclear.