Microsoft Recall is now an explorer.exe dependency
Recall integration with Explorer
- Thread centers on reports that Recall is now an Explorer dependency; some note it’s not a hard DLL dependency but more of a “dark pattern” integration that’s hard to fully disable.
- Others say disabling Recall via DISM currently works and preserves the modern Explorer UI, though people fear it could be silently re‑enabled by future updates.
- Comparisons are drawn to past tying of IE to the OS and to other hard‑to‑remove Windows components.
Privacy, surveillance, and security concerns
- Many see Recall (periodic screenshots plus AI search) as “spyware‑like,” especially since it records sensitive screens (PHI, legal work, trade secrets).
- Even if data is local, users object to CPU usage and attack surface; people recall earlier versions storing screenshots in an unencrypted DB.
- One comment cites Microsoft documentation that Recall uses a local model in a virtualized secure enclave with TPM‑encrypted storage; others immediately question how long that will remain unbreakable, given past security issues.
Debloating and mitigation strategies
- Numerous tools/scripts are recommended: O&O ShutUp10++, various Win11 “debloat” scripts, privacy.sexy, Blackbird, winutil, Ameliorated builds, and switching to LTSC/IoT Enterprise SKUs.
- Some warn these scripts often break Windows, especially feature updates and Windows Update itself.
- There’s irony noted: users worried about Microsoft telemetry still run unvetted privileged scripts from random repos.
- Others argue consent matters: they’d rather risk self‑inflicted damage than accept unasked‑for features like Recall and Copilot.
Linux as alternative
- Large subthread: “just switch to Linux.” Some report successful full‑time moves (often with Steam/Proton and Lutris), saying Windows now feels hostile and ad‑ridden.
- Others push back: Linux still lacks key commercial apps (Adobe suite, high‑end CAD like SolidWorks/Revit, some photography tools, vendor device software, robust VR support). For these users, Windows remains mandatory.
- Several advocate dual‑boot, GPU‑passthrough VMs, or “Windows To Go” external SSD installs so Windows is used only when needed.
Gaming, VR, and hardware support
- Proton is praised for near‑complete game support, but anticheat systems and niche peripherals (steering wheels, VR headsets like Valve Index) remain pain points.
- Experiences conflict: some report Rocket League and various VR titles working fine under Proton/SteamVR; others describe broken compositors, calibration issues, and missing drivers/TrueForce features.
Developer experience and user attitudes
- Some developers say Linux is the best environment for server‑side/web work; others find Windows (especially with Visual Studio/.NET or WSL) equally or more productive.
- Several note that most ordinary Windows users neither know nor care about these issues; power users feel “trapped” by app/driver lock‑in and increasingly see Windows as indistinguishable from malware.