Air Canada to remove free carry-on from basic economy

Policy Details & Definitions

• Change applies to “basic economy” fares: free overhead-bin carry-on removed, but one smaller “personal item” (handbag, laptop bag, small backpack) still allowed if it fits under the seat.
• Multiple comments stress that “personal item” ≠ “carry-on,” though some smaller backpacks can count as personal items depending on size and airline rules.

Rationale, Unbundling & “Gouging” Debate

• Supporters frame this as unbundling: pay only for what you use, enabling lower sticker prices and more options for highly price‑sensitive travelers.
• Critics argue prices don’t actually drop; instead, the same or higher total cost buys fewer services (“shrinkflation / hidden price hike”).
• Some emphasize airlines’ thin profit margins and inflation, saying “gouging” is misused; others counter with executive pay and high absolute fares.

Overhead Bins, Checked Bags & Incentives

• Overhead bins are routinely full; gate-checking is common and stressful.
• Many avoid checking bags due to lost/lated luggage, theft, damage, and long waits at carousels—problems several say are especially bad with certain carriers/airports.
• Some think airlines created the bin problem by charging for checked bags, pushing passengers to carry on more. Suggestion: reverse incentives—free checked bag, paid carry-on with guaranteed bin space.

Comparisons to Other Airlines & Markets

• WestJet and some U.S. and European low-cost carriers already charge for standard carry-ons; this is seen as competitive pressure on Air Canada.
• Disagreement over how widespread free carry-on remains in Europe; distinction between legacy carriers vs low-cost carriers.

Passenger Experience, Behavior & Extremes

• Complaints about “gate humping,” oversized roller bags, and cognitive load from complex fare structures.
• Some would gladly trade comfort and amenities for cheaper fares; others say economy is the only realistic option and is being degraded.
• Various tongue‑in‑cheek ideas (standing-room tickets, pay-per-use toilets, luggage-loading for points) highlight fears of ongoing “enshittification.”
• Concern raised about how strict baggage policies might impact travelers with disabilities or temperature‑sensitive medications.