Lenovo has removed the TrackPoint nub from new ThinkPad laptops

Original Article ↗ Hacker News Discussion ↗

Lenovo’s decision to drop the iconic red TrackPoint pointing stick from certain new ThinkPad models has triggered debate over both usability and brand identity. Many long-time users argue the nub is faster, more precise, and ergonomically superior to trackpads—especially for keyboard-centric workflows and cramped spaces—while others see it as an outdated relic now that large, high-quality touchpads are common. Several comments frame its removal as part of a broader trend of ThinkPads becoming more MacBook-like and losing distinctive, productivity-focused hardware features.

Scope of the Change

  • Removal of the TrackPoint is limited to specific new “Aura Edition” ThinkPad models (14" and 15").
  • Lenovo states TrackPoint will remain on other ThinkPad lines, but many see this as testing how far the brand can be altered.

Utility and User Experience

  • Strong split in opinions:
    • Fans say TrackPoint is faster and more precise, especially for keyboard-centric workflows, coding, REPL use, drag-and-drop, and cramped spaces (airplanes, laps).
    • Key advantages cited: hands stay on home row, infinite cursor range (velocity-based), easy three-button use, and better ergonomics than small or mediocre touchpads.
    • Critics find it imprecise, unnecessary now that large touchpads are good, and say they never use it or disable it.
  • Several users rely on it almost exclusively; others never touch it and prefer an external mouse.

Ergonomics and Health

  • Some report pain or RSI from the backpressure of the strain-gauge stick.
  • Others claim it reduces wrist strain versus touchpads since palms can rest naturally.
  • Having both TrackPoint and touchpad is valued by some to vary posture and reduce discomfort.

Reliability and Drift

  • Reports of cursor drift over time; some attribute it to wear, others to long sustained pressure or the screen pressing on the nub when closed.
  • Counter-claims note that drivers can auto-compensate for drift, though behavior varies by model.

Brand, Strategy, and Product Direction

  • Many view the TrackPoint as an iconic ThinkPad differentiator; removing it is seen as diluting the brand and mimicking MacBooks.
  • Some argue this is a recurring pattern: Lenovo makes “design” changes (removing buttons, changing aspect ratios, moving exhaust, killing classic keyboards), then partially walks them back after backlash.
  • Others feel the ThinkPad value is broader (durability, serviceability, Linux support, keyboard layout) and not solely about the nub.

Keyboards, Layouts, and Alternatives

  • Strong dissatisfaction with newer ThinkPad keyboards: reduced key travel, altered layouts (missing Right Ctrl, tighter function key grouping, tiny arrows).
  • Many desire classic layouts (e.g., older T/X series, 7‑row keyboards).
  • Standalone TrackPoint keyboards from Lenovo are appreciated for desktops, KVMs, HTPCs, and small spaces.
  • Several lament that non-Apple laptops still trail Apple’s trackpads in feel and software, though some users with RSI cannot tolerate any touchpad.