Widespread power outage in Spain and Portugal
Scale and immediate impact
- Commenters across Portugal and Spain report simultaneous loss of power, including major cities (Madrid, Barcelona, Valencia, Lisbon) and Andorra; parts of France briefly affected, Italy largely not.
- Traffic lights, metros, some airports, and water systems were disrupted; people avoid driving due to chaotic intersections.
- Outage duration varied widely by area (from under an hour to most of the day), with some regions cheering when power returned.
Interconnected grid and cascade behaviour
- Multiple comments explain that most of continental Europe is a single synchronous AC grid; Iberia is relatively weakly connected (low interconnect capacity) but still coupled.
- A failure in one part can cause frequency excursions, triggering automatic trips of generators and lines, leading to cascading disconnections until the disturbance “runs into” a more resilient area.
- Others note earlier near-miss or regional European incidents with similar dynamics (frequency drops, underfrequency load shedding, distributed generation tripping out).
Cause: emerging picture, still debated
- Early media and operator statements suggest a “rare atmospheric phenomenon” causing large temperature variations in interior Spain, leading to oscillations (“induced atmospheric vibration” / conductor gallop) on 400 kV lines and synchronization failures.
- Some reports previously pointed to a fire in southern France damaging a high‑voltage line, but the French operator later denied a direct link.
- Several commenters caution against premature cyberattack theories and criticize sensational reporting; cause still treated as not fully resolved.
Black start and restoration process
- Grid engineers describe how widespread trips force a staged restart (“black start”‑like), bringing generators and regions online gradually while keeping frequency near 50 Hz.
- Iberian TSOs reportedly restarted from the north and south, using domestic hydro and thermal plants and progressively decoupling from Spain/reequilibrating.
- Multiple links to ENTSO‑E data show a sharp drop of ~15 GW in Spanish demand and near‑total loss of certain generation types, followed by steady recovery at a controlled pace.
Telecoms and critical infrastructure
- Mobile networks, fibre backhaul, and data centres generally stayed up for hours on batteries and generators, though capacity degraded and some regions lost coverage entirely.
- Old PSTN and telco design culture of extreme survivability is discussed; hospitals, airports, and exchanges usually have substantial backup.
Cashless society, resilience, and behaviour
- Lack of ATMs and card systems during the outage revives arguments for keeping cash and low‑tech fallbacks (paper receipts, manual ledgers).
- Others argue that multi‑hour nationwide blackouts are so rare that mandating home batteries or cash handling everywhere would be disproportionate; debate centers on where to place resilience (household vs grid vs critical infrastructure).
Renewables, inertia, and grid design
- Some point out Spain was recently operating at very high renewable shares; they suspect low “spinning” inertia made the system more fragile to disturbances.
- Engineers push back on simplistic “blame renewables” narratives: inverter‑based resources can be programmed to provide synthetic inertia and grid‑forming behaviour, but many small solar/wind units today simply disconnect on anomalies.
- There is detailed discussion of frequency control, load shedding schemes, and the difficulty of managing a high‑renewables, highly distributed grid during black and brown starts.
Markets, regulation, and investment
- Comparisons are drawn to the 2003 US Northeast blackout, UK and Texas events, and Balkan outages; commenters stress that big failures are usually multi‑factor (technical, operational, and economic).
- Some emphasize that incentives and regulation (capacity markets, black‑start payments, maintenance budgets) shape resilience more than technology alone.
- Others argue the event will likely spur more investment in grid hardening, storage, and possibly strategic spares, but note past experience shows such investigations and reforms take months or years.