Microplastics shed by food packaging are contaminating our food, study finds
Ubiquity of Microplastics and Food Contamination
- Several commenters argue microplastics are now everywhere in the food system: in soils, manure fertilizer, store-bought potting soil, irrigation water, and even organic home gardens.
- Point is made that avoiding industrial food or eating low on the food chain may reduce but not eliminate exposure.
Learned Helplessness vs. Action
- Some express “learned helplessness” given global spread; others counter that discussing the issue, using less plastic, and supporting alternatives can still shift norms and policy.
- Suggested actions: vote for parties with anti-plastic agendas, support activist groups, prefer non-plastic packaging, pressure manufacturers, and extend producer responsibility.
Health Risks: Known, Suspected, and Unclear
- Commenters note evidence of microplastics and additives (e.g., BPA, PFAS) affecting hormones, fertility, and possibly cancer and cardiovascular risk.
- Others emphasize that for many endpoints, harmful doses, mechanisms, and real-world impacts are still unclear and under active study.
- Some think concern borders on “mass hysteria” without conclusive human data.
Trade-offs: Plastics vs. Food Safety and Waste
- Strong counterpoint: plastic packaging greatly reduces spoilage, pathogen exposure, and food waste, which historically killed people.
- Debate over how many deaths plastics actually prevented versus older systems (glass, metal, waxed paper, local fresh foods).
- Multiple comments stress these are trade-offs, not simple “plastic bad” stories.
Historical Analogies (Lead, Asbestos, CFCs)
- Many compare plastics to past hazards like lead, asbestos, CFCs, PFAS: harms recognized late; regulation slow due to industry resistance and human difficulty with delayed consequences.
- Others argue microplastic risk is likely far below that of lead and should not be conflated.
Alternatives and Hidden Plastics
- Past and potential alternatives mentioned: glass, metal, waxed/waxed-paper, reusable containers, bulk stores.
- Several note that “paper” or “metal” packaging is often plastic-lined; even glass bottles can be contaminated via plasticized caps.
- Some report disappointment that new glassware or parchment paper still involve polymers.
Other Major Microplastic Sources
- Clothing, carpets, dryer lint, household dust, and tire wear are flagged as major, often overlooked sources—possibly larger than food packaging.
- Indoor inhalation of synthetic fibers may be a major exposure route.
Proposed Technical and Policy Solutions
- Ideas include engineered microbes to digest plastics (with concerns about unintended degradation of useful plastics), and “total liability” regimes where producers share legal responsibility for diffuse harms.
- Others warn that extreme liability could cripple technological economies and that regulations, while imperfect, address obvious failures (e.g., fire codes).
Data, Measurement, and Hype
- Some question the tone of the CNN piece as “breathless” and fault it for emphasizing scary particle counts without context (e.g., comparison with other particles).
- Commenters share resources like plasticlist.org and recent microplastic-in-glass studies, noting surprising results (e.g., high plastic signals in some “healthy” or supposedly safer products).