I'm done with social media – Or: why I have a blog now
Distinct Skills: Craft vs “Being Good at Social”
- Many agree that being a good writer, programmer, or creator is a different skill from being a social media performer; the overlap is limited.
- Several recount meeting excellent engineers/authors whose online posts are shallow or even misleading because the format rewards pith over accuracy.
- A recurring point: if social media comes naturally and you already have an audience, it can help; but “joining to promote a book/product” rarely works.
Social Media as Pyramid Scheme / Attention Game
- Commenters resonate with the author’s “pyramid scheme” framing: platforms need endless new creators to feed engagement while only a few benefit.
- Social media is reframed as a massively multiplayer game where the objective is followers and “internet points,” often detached from real expertise.
- Algorithms are seen as optimizing for addiction and outrage, not value; feeds have drifted from social graphs to engagement-maximizing entertainment.
LinkedIn, Facebook, and Manipulative Growth Tactics
- Strong disdain for LinkedIn’s feed, vanity posts, and aggressive notifications. Advice: treat it as a static resume and referral tool, not a place to “be active.”
- Facebook’s auto-login “magic links” from marketing emails are viewed as disrespectful and insecure, seemingly used to inflate “active user” metrics.
- Users describe both platforms as spammy, low-signal, and full of hype or outright fabrications about professional accomplishment.
Mental Health, Addiction, and Harmful Content
- Multiple people describe quitting or heavily restricting Reddit, Instagram, TikTok, etc., citing anxiety, doomscrolling, and constant distraction.
- A vivid example: waking up to an algorithmically served execution video, leading to day-long anxiety and a decision to “log off.”
- Some argue moderation at scale is inherently imperfect; others focus less on moderation and more on the inherent harms of slot-machine-style short video.
Minimal Phones, Boredom, and Analog Habits
- Several report switching to feature phones or stripping smartphones of apps, rediscovering boredom, deeper focus, and enjoyment of movies/books.
- There’s debate whether this is niche “chattering class” backlash or an early sign of broader pushback against pervasive, attention-draining tech.
Alternatives: Blogs, RSS, Small Networks
- Strong enthusiasm for blogs, email newsletters, and RSS as “pure,” user-controlled tech for following creators without algorithms.
- People highlight small forums, IRC, Discord servers, private group chats, and self-hosted sites as closer to the “old internet” and more genuinely social.
- Some envision paid, small-scale social platforms (limited connections, no ads, no algorithmic feed) or LLM-based personal filters sitting between users and feeds.
Using Social Media Strategically (or Not at All)
- Some insist social media can still be powerful if used surgically: posting substantive work into niche communities, guesting on established channels, or treating platforms as write-only broadcast outlets.
- Others conclude that for many careers and small businesses, the requirement to be a constant “personal brand” is mentally unsustainable, and that word-of-mouth, curated channels, and owned platforms (blogs/newsletters) are healthier long-term.