Ask HN: How can we solve the loneliness epidemic?
OP’s Street Signs and Low-Stakes Contact
- OP combats their own loneliness by standing on a Chicago corner with signs like “How alone do you feel?” and collecting anonymous answers.
- Passers-by report looking forward to the signs; some say they helped them through hospitalizations or rough periods.
- Suggestions include turning this into a “pyramid” of low-effort sign-holders, organizing ad‑hoc coffee meetups advertised on the sign, or using it as a seed for a broader movement of gentle, low-pressure public contact.
- OP struggles with the next step: moving from shared pain (“we both feel 100% alone”) to real relationship without it feeling hollow or one-sided.
How Loneliness Feels and Where It Comes From
- Many describe severe childhood trauma, abuse, or neglect that left them convinced they’re unlovable and socially “behind,” with warped attachment styles.
- Others feel discarded by work- and school-centered social structures as they age, divorce, or fall out of standard roles.
- Several note that volunteer or helping roles provide purpose but don’t fully answer the need to feel personally known and cared about.
Individual Strategies People Recommend
- Repeated advice: “be the organizer” – host dinners, trivia teams, board-game nights, running clubs, block BBQs, church small groups, etc.
- Become a “regular” at third places (bars, coffee shops, libraries, skateparks, gyms, churches) where routine and familiarity slowly build ties.
- Join activities that require showing up with others: team sports, dance, martial arts, choirs, amateur theater, local politics, parenting groups.
- Volunteering (soup kitchens, shelters, community cleanups, tech meetups) is widely cited as an antidote, with the caveat that it can become one‑way and exhausting.
Community, Third Places, and Urban Design
- Many blame suburban sprawl, car dependence, zoning that bans mixed-use, and the loss/privatization of “third places” for making casual contact rare and expensive.
- Proposals include: more free or cheap community spaces, library-based cafes and makerspaces, cohousing/tiny neighborhoods, walkable neighborhoods, and support for social clubs and local sports.
Technology and Social Media
- Strong theme: social media and smartphones absorb the “itch” that used to push people out the door, while teaching habits (doomscrolling, edginess) that harm offline relations.
- Some call for regulating engagement algorithms, limiting youth access, or even “destroying social media”; others argue tech also enables real communities and friendships when used intentionally.
- A few propose new tech: hyperlocal social networks, AI-assisted matching, or apps that push people into real-life meetups; many respondents are skeptical that more software is the answer.
Religion and Institutional Belonging
- Several argue that regular churchgoing effectively reduces loneliness via ritual, shared purpose, and multigenerational community.
- Others share experiences of shallow or manipulative church relationships, or outright abuse, and reject religion as a reliable solution.
Is There Really an “Epidemic”?
- Some participants question the “epidemic” framing, citing survey data showing most people still report being satisfied with their personal lives.
- Others counter that satisfaction scores are at historic lows, and that visible rises in teen suicide and despair suggest something is deeply wrong.
Structural vs Personal Responsibility
- One camp emphasizes personal agency: get off screens, accept awkwardness, practice social skills, and keep showing up.
- Another stresses structural causes: economic precarity, housing costs, urban form, the decline of unions and civic groups, and attention-maximizing platforms; they argue policy and design changes are needed, not just “try harder” advice.
- Broad (if implicit) consensus: loneliness arises from both inner wounds and external systems, and any serious response must address both.