New Withings Users Must Pay $99/Year for Apple Health Syncing

Withings has begun charging new users $99 per year to sync data from its scales and other devices to Apple Health, turning what many see as core functionality into a subscription add‑on. Commenters condemn the move as part of a broader “enshittification” trend in consumer hardware and apps, arguing that simple Bluetooth-to-phone syncing should not require cloud services or recurring fees. Many say they will avoid future Withings products, look for simpler or open alternatives, or rely on reverse engineering and third‑party tools to retain access to their own health data.

Reaction to Paywalled Health Sync

  • Most commenters see the $99/year Apple Health sync fee for new accounts as blatant rent-seeking on user-owned data.
  • Many say this was their primary reason for buying Withings devices and now vow never to buy Withings again, even if existing accounts are grandfathered.
  • Some suggest returning products (especially bought via Apple Store) and explicitly citing the new paywall as the reason, hoping to trigger retailer pressure.
  • A minority argue ongoing software/R&D and infrastructure costs justify subscriptions, but this view is heavily contested.

Technical and Architectural Critiques

  • Sync path is widely criticized: scale → Wi‑Fi → Internet → Withings cloud → app → HealthKit, instead of simple local Bluetooth → app → HealthKit.
  • Several users report long-standing bugs, flaky syncing, forced logins, bloated apps, and poor customer support.
  • Apple App Store guideline 4.10 (no monetizing built-in OS capabilities) is cited; some think Withings may be in violation, others argue the fee targets their backend, not Apple APIs directly.

Subscriptions, Business Models, and “Enshittification”

  • The move is framed as part of a broader pattern: turning purchased hardware into a funnel for recurring revenue (compared to BMW heated seats, Ecobee thermostat ads, Canon account requirements, Nordictrack/iFit, YouTube Premium features).
  • Several commenters say this destroys resale value and reinforces the idea that users don’t own devices, they are “revenue streams.”
  • Some expect PR spin, a temporary backlash, then quiet entrenchment unless revenue suffers enough.

Reverse Engineering and Open Alternatives

  • Strong expectation that community tools will bypass the paywall via Bluetooth/ESP32, Home Assistant, or custom clients; multiple existing projects are already linked (e.g., Gadgetbridge, various GitHub repos).
  • LLMs and agent-based tools are seen as dramatically lowering reverse-engineering effort, but there’s concern this will push vendors toward stronger crypto and remote attestation.

Alternatives and “Dumb” Devices

  • Many recommend cheaper scales (Renpho, Wyze, Beurer, Tanita, Garmin, generic Amazon brands) that sync locally or to Apple/Google health, or just “dumb” $20 scales plus manual entry.
  • Several argue most advanced metrics (body fat %, calories, etc.) are inaccurate anyway; a simple, reliable weight trend is enough.