Cuban: Facebook knowingly runs AI deepfake scam ads; docs say $16B fraud revenue

Facebook and other major ad platforms are accused of knowingly profiting from large-scale fraud, including AI-generated deepfake scam ads that impersonate public figures and push bogus investments or products. Commenters debate whether existing laws like Section 230 are adequate, argue that platforms and advertisers should bear legal liability for fraudulent ads, and point to weak incentives and regulation as reasons big tech tolerates scams. Many see the broader ad-tech model—driven by surveillance, engagement optimization, and minimal vetting—as inherently prone to abuse and harmful to users and society.

Prevalence of Scam Ads Across Platforms

  • Many participants say scammy or clearly deceptive ads are now ubiquitous on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, Google, Amazon, eBay, and other platforms.
  • Examples include fake investment schemes using celebrity likenesses, miracle health products, impossible gadget claims, counterfeit goods, illegal drugs, and even content hinting at child abuse material.
  • Several people report that essentially “every other ad” or “half of all ads” they see are obvious scams.

Meta’s Knowledge and Internal Incentives

  • A cited Reuters investigation says Meta internally projected about 10% of annual revenue (~$16B) comes from fraudulent or banned ads.
  • Documents reportedly show Meta only bans advertisers when automated systems are ≥95% confident they’re scams; below that, ads stay live but pay higher rates.
  • Some with advertising or internal experience claim Meta relaxes enforcement for large spenders.

User Experiences and Harm

  • Multiple reports of users and relatives losing money to scam ads; some victims are elderly.
  • Many say they repeatedly report blatantly fraudulent or disturbing ads and get “no violation found” responses.
  • This fosters distrust and the sense that platforms prioritize revenue over safety.

Legal Liability and Section 230 Debate

  • One camp argues removing or reforming Section 230, especially for paid ads, would force platforms to vet advertisers like traditional media.
  • Others counter that:
    • Section 230 already doesn’t shield criminal conduct.
    • Removing it would mostly entrench giants who can afford lawsuits and destroy smaller forums.
  • There’s disagreement over whether social media are “publishers” in the legal sense and whether legal definitions should change.

AI, Automation, and Responsibility

  • Some discuss using AI to automatically detect and block scam ads, noting platforms already use sophisticated profiling for advertising.
  • Others stress automation should not reduce liability: if a company deploys AI that approves scams, the company should still be responsible.
  • Analogies are drawn to bridge engineering, self‑driving cars, and dangerous tools: the human organization that deploys the system should bear the risk.

Proposed Remedies and Regulation

  • Ideas include:
    • Making platforms legally liable for fraudulent ads they distribute.
    • “Know your customer” rules for advertisers.
    • Killing or limiting algorithmic feeds; returning to chronological, opt‑in content.
    • Stronger consumer protection and criminal enforcement, especially for large platforms.
    • More radical proposals: banning online ads, or moving ads into regulated, consumer‑run product directories.

Broader Critique of Advertising and Platforms

  • Many see ad‑tech as intrinsically misaligned with user interests, optimizing manipulation and attention capture.
  • Some argue that the normalization of scams reflects deeper issues: weak regulation, profit‑driven indifference, and a culture that tolerates deceptive marketing.