Asahi Linux Progress Linux 7.3
Efforts to run Linux natively on Apple Silicon are splintering, with Asahi Linux emphasizing upstreamable, human-reviewed code and a new shift from MIT to GPL licensing, while newer projects like Omarchy and Gravity Linux embrace LLM‑assisted, faster-but-rougher development. Commenters weigh trade-offs between long-term maintainability, security, and hardware safety versus rapid feature support for newer Macs, including GPUs, Thunderbolt, Touch ID, and high-refresh displays. Underneath is a broader debate about software freedom, permissive vs copyleft licensing, and whether AI-generated “slop” is an acceptable price for quickly unlocking Apple’s high-end hardware for Linux users.
Asahi’s Progress and Focus
- Commenters praise steady Asahi advances (Fedora Asahi Remix shipping same day as Fedora 45, new Thunderbolt work, ongoing GPU and display work).
- Emphasis on upstream-first development and long‑term maintainability, even if this slows visible feature rollout.
- Some users already daily‑drive it, others are waiting on specific features like robust USB‑C / external display support and easier full‑disk encryption.
Motivation: Apple Hardware, macOS, and Control
- Many see Apple Silicon laptops as unmatched on hardware (battery life, thermals, displays, build quality).
- macOS is often described as locked‑down, “for normies,” or increasingly user‑hostile; people want “real Linux” on that hardware for control and ownership.
- Others argue most users don’t care this deeply; they value reliability more than hackability.
Omarchy: Fast Features vs. Code Quality
- Omarchy is seen by fans as delivering “no‑compromises Linux on Mac” quickly using LLM‑assisted reverse engineering and preconfigured desktop setups.
- Critics call it “vibe‑coded slop”: huge, non‑reviewed AI patches, poor driver architecture (e.g., Touch ID in‑kernel), security and maintainability worries, and no realistic path upstream.
- Some are happy to accept risky, non‑upstreamable code if it makes their machines work now; others refuse to trust such code with their hardware and data.
Gravity Linux and Other Forks
- Gravity Linux is introduced as an LLM‑friendly, upstream‑oriented fork claiming Vulkan 1.4, advanced GPU features, and early M4/M5 support, but still alpha and not yet “shipped” as a polished distro.
- Its own admission of “horrific” early driver code and an aggressive tone lead some to blacklist it; others are excited by faster progress.
Licensing Shift and AI Tension
- Asahi is moving from MIT to GPLv2+ due to code being lifted from private branches, lightly obfuscated with LLMs, and monetized without attribution.
- Debate centers on permissive vs copyleft licenses, fairness of forks monetizing upstream work, and whether GPL actually deters bad actors or AI training.
- Broader split: some view AI‑heavy workflows as essential acceleration; others see them as producing low‑quality patches, legal/ethical issues, and long‑term ecosystem damage.