When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
Raspberry Pi’s top-end 5 model with 16 GB RAM now selling for around $385 has become a flashpoint for broader frustration over soaring hardware and memory prices, driven in part by AI data-center demand. Commenters argue the board no longer fits the original “affordable computing for learning” mission and is a poor value compared with used mini‑PCs, thin clients, phones, or microcontrollers, especially for general computing or home servers. Many see the 16 GB SKU as unnecessary for most hobbyist use, question Raspberry Pi Ltd.’s lock‑down of RAM upgrades, and predict either a future price crash when the AI bubble bursts or a long-term shift toward repurposing older hardware and more efficient software.
RAM & AI-Driven Price Explosion
- Many commenters tie Pi 5 pricing directly to a global RAM crunch, driven by AI/data center demand.
- Disagreement on trajectory:
- Some expect a bubble burst and eventual price crash (possibly after used data center hardware floods the market).
- Others argue entrenched oligopoly/cartel behavior means high prices could persist, likening RAM to designer goods or gasoline.
- Several note that LPDDR4X for Pis shares wafers/fab capacity with high-end GPU/HBM RAM, so AI demand indirectly pushes up Pi memory costs.
- Older DDR3/DDR4 prices are also spiking, as production shifts to more profitable lines.
Raspberry Pi Pricing, Mission Drift, and Usefulness
- Many feel the high price of the 16GB Pi 5 contradicts the original “low-cost computing for learning” mission.
- Some argue the Pi is now effectively an industrial/embedded product first; the foundation’s educational role has shifted toward microcontrollers (RP2040/RP2350).
- Several state that 16GB on a Pi is overkill for most hobby/embedded tasks and a poor value compared with mini PCs or used hardware.
- Others say most users should simply ignore the 16GB SKU and stick to 1–8GB models, or even older Pi 2/3/4 boards.
RAM Lockdown and Modification Controversy
- Strong criticism of firmware changes that block RAM “reballing” (upgrading memory chips).
- Defenders claim this protects the supply chain and users from counterfeit/modified boards and arbitrage.
- Workarounds involve downgrading to older bootloaders; newer bootloaders are signed and enforce RAM checks.
Alternatives to Raspberry Pi
- Commonly suggested replacements:
- Used mini PCs, thin clients, and off-lease workstations for servers/desktops.
- ESP32/RP2040-class microcontrollers for GPIO/embedded tasks.
- Old smartphones or Android TV boxes (with caveats: batteries, malware, locked bootloaders).
- Other SBCs (BeagleBone, Libre Computer, etc.), though none fully match Pi’s ecosystem + price + longevity.
Appropriate Use Cases & Performance Tips
- Consensus: Pi shines as a low-power embedded Linux board with GPIO, not as a main desktop/server.
- Many former “Pi as server” users have moved to x86 mini PCs instead.
- For performance, several recommend:
- Booting from SSD/NVMe instead of SD.
- Generous swap on SSD rather than chasing very high RAM sizes (while acknowledging SSD wear concerns).
Broader AI/Monopoly Concerns
- Some see the AI build-out as a way for hyperscalers to monopolize compute: buying most new hardware so individuals are pushed toward renting cloud resources.
- Others view the current situation as a classic speculative bubble whose pop would normalize consumer hardware prices, but timing and magnitude are considered uncertain.