Don't buy AR glasses
Warnings that AR glasses could turn everyday life into an ad-saturated, surveilled “hyper-reality” are colliding with enthusiasm for their practical benefits as navigation aids, portable monitors, and heads-up displays. Commenters draw parallels to smartphones and smart TVs, arguing that once the hardware is mainstream, platforms and advertisers will push intrusive tracking and locked-down ecosystems, with bystanders’ privacy at particular risk. Others counter that open-source hardware, “dumb” display-only glasses, user norms, and regulation—especially in places like the EU—could reclaim the technology’s advantages without accepting pervasive surveillance.
Comparison to Smartphones & Digital Minimalism
- Many see the anti-AR argument as similar to past “don’t buy smartphones” pleas.
- Some argue smartphones already went too far; they want “phone-lite” or dumb-phone setups, minimal apps, and fewer distractions.
- Others say utility always wins: if AR enables things phones can’t, mass adoption is likely despite risks.
Ads, Monetization & Platform Lock-In
- Strong concern that AR will follow the pattern of web/TV/OS shittification: ad coverage grows until platforms themselves are ad channels.
- Counterpoint: competition and user pushback can limit excess ads; critics respond that capitalism tends toward monopolies that can abuse users anyway.
- Fear that AR will be more locked down than phones: remote attestation, no sideloading, tighter control, similar to smartwatches/TVs.
Privacy, Surveillance & Bystander Rights
- Persistent worry about always-on cameras, facial recognition, and behavioral logging in public.
- Some liken AR wearers to walking spy cameras/wiretaps; suggest such “pervert glasses” should be banned until social/legal norms catch up.
- Others hope open hardware/OS can resist the surveillance state; critics reply that people-identification apps and ecosystem incentives will reintroduce surveillance anyway.
“Dumb” Display Glasses vs Full AR
- Strong enthusiasm for “display glasses” / HMDs that are just external screens (e.g., for travel, gaming, posture), with no sensors or platform lock-in.
- Debates over terminology (HMD, XR glasses, display glasses) and whether current products are truly AR.
- Screen quality, FOV, edge blurriness, and 1080p limits are recurring complaints; 4K micro‑OLED is seen as the next big step.
Use Cases & Hoped-For Benefits
- Positive visions: bigger portable displays, HUD-style status, notifications above eye line, exercise/swim metrics, biking directions, lab safety, directions while traveling, translation, tabletop gaming, ad-blocking overlays for the real world.
- Some see AR as a way to hide the phone and reduce low-priority interruptions if designed well.
Social Acceptance, Regulation & Resistance
- Many find AR glasses creepy and voyeuristic; expect social stigma, mockery, or even physical hostility like with early Google Glass.
- Some regions reportedly already consider bans; others pin hopes on EU-style regulation as the only effective defense.
- A minority dismiss the article as premature ranting; others see value in warning early, even if tech’s spread seems inevitable.