LibreOffice actually works 365 days a year
A marketing jab from LibreOffice claiming it “works 365 days a year” amid a major Microsoft 365 outage reignites the long‑running comparison between free, offline office suites and cloud‑centric platforms like Office 365 and Google Docs. Commenters weigh trade‑offs among cost, security updates, UI quality, feature completeness, file compatibility, and the importance of real‑time collaboration and broader ecosystem integration (email, calendaring, device management). Many see LibreOffice as sufficient or even preferable for individual and home use, but argue that network effects, interoperability, and cloud workflows keep Microsoft dominant in professional and enterprise settings.
Scope of the Discussion
- Thread reacts to LibreOffice’s “works 365 days a year” jab at Microsoft 365 during a major outage.
- Focus areas: offline vs cloud, cost and updates, UI/UX, compatibility, collaboration, and maturity of office software.
Offline vs Cloud, Cost, and Updates
- Many note that perpetual, fully offline Microsoft Office versions still exist and work fine.
- Criticism: these versions eventually lose security updates, pushing users to pay again; timing of releases can shorten effective lifespan.
- Counterpoint: one‑time purchases are not inherently “owed” free updates; vendors sell updates to fund ongoing development.
- Some compare security fixes to product recalls in other industries and argue critical fixes should be free.
Functionality and Maturity
- Several argue word processors are effectively “finished”; new features matter little to typical users.
- Others highlight newer Excel functions and advanced features (macros, mail merge) as real value.
- Mixed experiences: some say LibreOffice lets them do tasks they couldn’t in MS Office; others report crashes or limits with CSVs and large/wide spreadsheets.
UI/UX and Perceived Quality
- A common complaint is that LibreOffice looks old or ugly, especially on macOS (non-native feel, sluggish dialogs, low-res icons).
- Others prefer its denser, classic menus over the Microsoft Ribbon and consider modern Office’s UI worse.
- Comparisons to GIMP vs Photoshop: powerful but “janky” UX; calls for a Blender‑style UI overhaul and structured usability testing with Office users.
Compatibility with Microsoft Office
- Interoperability is a recurring pain point.
- Some report LibreOffice is ~95% compatible and rarely fails on real documents.
- Others say complex or legal Word documents and intricate formatting still break, and round‑tripping with Office users is unreliable.
- This compatibility gap is seen as a key reason businesses stick with Microsoft.
Collaboration, Ecosystem, and Cloud
- Many argue Microsoft 365’s real product is the integrated cloud: email, calendars, Teams, shared storage, real‑time collaboration, search.
- LibreOffice is seen as primarily a local file editor; Collabora/LO Online exist but are not viewed as equivalent to the Microsoft ecosystem.
- Critics say boasting about “365 days” misses that the outage was in cloud/groupware, not basic document editing.
Reliability and Performance
- Supporters emphasize that offline apps are immune to cloud outages and internet issues.
- Others respond that overall uptime of professionally run cloud services often exceeds that of locally managed stacks.
- Performance reports are mixed: LibreOffice is said to start instantly on Linux but noticeably slower on Windows; antivirus and platform specifics are suspected.
Adoption, Inertia, and Philosophy
- One side claims if LibreOffice were “good enough” it would already be popular.
- Others cite network effects, MS bundling, corporate sales pressure, and document lock‑in as stronger forces than pure quality.
- Some users prioritize open formats and data longevity over polish or integration, donating to LibreOffice instead of paying for 365.