KDE: The documentary [video]

A new independent documentary on the history of the KDE desktop environment is prompting users to reflect on three decades of Linux desktop evolution, from KDE’s early “Kool Desktop Environment” roots and the rough KDE 4 era to today’s polished Plasma 6. Commenters largely praise modern KDE for its performance, customizability and ecosystem (from KWin to KDE Connect), often contrasting it favorably with GNOME, macOS, and Windows, while also noting past licensing conflicts around Qt and differing project philosophies. Some criticize the film as overly promotional and light on controversy or recent governance details, but many see it as an inspiring look at long-term volunteer-driven software.

Reception of the documentary

  • Many found it high-quality, engaging, and inspiring, especially seeing the human side and long history of KDE.
  • Several appreciated learning about early goals (e.g., “Kool Desktop Environment,” anti‑CDE positioning, KHTML → Apple).
  • Some criticized it as a “sunshine/promo video” that glosses over painful episodes like KDE 4 and doesn’t deeply cover governance, internal conflicts, or the last 10–15 years of evolution.

KDE vs. GNOME and other desktops

  • Strong praise for KDE as the power‑user, highly configurable desktop; some say without KDE, Linux wouldn’t be viable as a daily driver for them.
  • Repeated complaints that GNOME feels “locked down,” “androidified,” or prescriptive; users feel “kneecapped” by limited configuration.
  • Counterpoints: GNOME’s minimalism and single workflow are defended as deliberate design; extensions are cited as powerful customization, and GNOME’s app ecosystem (GNOME Circle, GTK bindings) is praised.
  • Some see KDE as “wannabe Windows” by default; others argue all major desktops only superficially mimic each other and that deep UX ideas differ.

KDE’s evolution: 3.x → 4 → 5/6

  • KDE 3.5 is remembered fondly as extremely customizable and, for some, the best DE they’ve ever used.
  • KDE 4 is widely called a “disaster”: unstable, regressions, and poor communication about its readiness; many users defected to XFCE, tiling WMs, or macOS then.
  • Several report Plasma 5 mid‑cycle and especially Plasma 6 as fast, stable, and “finally back to 3.x‑level quality,” with smooth updates and many small quality‑of‑life improvements.
  • A minority still describe Plasma as “not really stable,” with numerous small bugs.

Features and ecosystem

  • KDE Connect is repeatedly described as a “killer app,” plus Dolphin, Konsole, KIO, KParts, Kdenlive, Krita, Okular, and strong integration for networking, audio, Bluetooth, and storage.
  • Some note KDE’s C++/Qt basis makes deep changes harder than GNOME extensions, though Qt now has bindings in more languages.

Comparisons with Windows/macOS

  • Many claim KDE feels more modern, ergonomic, and less bloated than current Windows or macOS, especially in window management and power features.
  • Others push back, noting KDE’s own bugs and rough edges, and arguing ergonomics are highly subjective and strongly shaped by familiarity.

Licensing, corporate backing, and distros

  • Discussion of GNOME’s origins in reaction to restrictive early Qt licensing; disagreement over how much dialogue existed at the time.
  • Qt Group is now commercially driven; some employees reportedly see the open‑source edition as a sales burden, but others note the Free Qt agreement protects openness and KDE’s contributions provide value.
  • Historically, GNOME had more paid distro‑backed developers; today both sides see fewer distro‑funded devs, with KDE getting notable support from Valve (SteamOS/Steam Deck, compositor work).
  • Fedora KDE is often recommended as a polished KDE distro; Kubuntu, Debian, and others are also mentioned.
  • For a KDE 3‑style experience, Trinity Desktop Environment, Q4OS, and “Klassik” on top of modern KDE are suggested.

Community, culture, and direction

  • Some note KDE historically leaned more European while GNOME leaned more American.
  • Observers remark on early KDE contributors now using macOS in the film; others explain many moved on to other careers, while current active contributors mostly run Plasma.
  • A critical thread argues that KDE today is not the same as in 2006–2007, citing changes like proposed donation daemons, systemd and Wayland dependencies, and shifting priorities; emphasizes that the documentary underplays these tensions.