Why did some Apollo missions carry a grenade launcher? (2019)

Apollo missions carrying a “grenade launcher” turn out to be using off‑the‑shelf mortar-like devices for seismic experiments on the Moon, not weapons, highlighting how technical choices can sound sensational out of context. Commenters use this as a springboard to compare moderation cultures on sites like Stack Exchange, Hacker News, Reddit, and X, especially around deleting jokes, enforcing seriousness, and accusations of “censorship.” The thread also touches on real weapons in spaceflight history—such as Soviet survival guns and armed space stations—to contrast popular myths with documented practice.

Moderation, Jokes, and Community Tone

  • Many comments react to Space.SE’s decision to delete joke comments on the question, seeing it as emblematic of Stack Exchange’s stricter, “no fun” direction.
  • Some argue this kind of pre-emptive deletion is off‑putting and reduces participation, versus downvotes where the community filters content organically.
  • Others defend strict moderation as necessary to maintain signal‑to‑noise and avoid Reddit‑style meme padding and karma farming.

Censorship, Free Speech, and Platform Control

  • One side criticizes heavy moderation and topic bans (on SE, Reddit, etc.) as “censor‑in‑the‑middle,” preferring to self‑filter rather than have content pre‑removed.
  • The opposing view stresses that private platforms are not obliged to host everything and that moderation is essential; calls for “no censorship” are seen as unrealistic.
  • There is brief debate over which mainstream platforms are more or less censored.

Technical and Ballistic Side Threads

  • Several comments riff on how far a grenade launcher or gun could fire on the Moon given low gravity and no drag, and whether a projectile could enter lunar orbit and return.
  • Others discuss difficulty of running on the Moon due to low friction and altered gait.
  • A technical excerpt from an Apollo manual describes remote “arm grenades” and “fire grenades” commands for the seismic experiment package.

Soviet Firearms and Survival Scenarios

  • Discussion notes that Soviet crews carried a survival gun due to remote Siberian landings with bears, wolves, and tigers; some think it’s excessive, others say rare but real attacks justify it.
  • There’s speculation that such weapons (or pills) might serve as last‑resort suicide tools in hopeless space situations, met with skepticism and counter‑arguments about practicality and optics.

Stack Exchange Meta and Site Health

  • Some see the question being closed as a duplicate and joke deletion as symptomatic of SE’s decline.
  • Others praise SE’s peak era for high‑quality, canonical Q&A, sometimes with users systematically asking and answering their own questions to build good references.
  • There are complaints about SE’s bot defenses blocking humans and about cookie banners listing hundreds of ad “partners.”