Why is Gemini 4 Carbon taking so long?
Gemini 4 Carbon, Google’s latest high-end AI coding model, is drawing mixed reactions for being markedly slower and more token-hungry than rivals while often producing deeper, more cautious and thorough work. Commenters attribute its latency to factors like test-time scaling, aggressive tool use, and Google’s weaker cost pressures compared with pure AI vendors, noting that it excels on complex, long-horizon tasks but feels impractical for everyday use. Many see it as a powerful planner and code reviewer best paired with faster models such as Gemini 4 Hydrogen, while others are frustrated by poor tooling, timeouts, and what they view as overengineering and benchmark-chasing.
Overall Theme
- Thread centers on why Gemini 4 Carbon feels so slow, whether that slowness is “broken” or intentional, and how its depth of reasoning compares to other frontier models.
Performance and Speed
- Many report extremely slow time-to-first-token (seconds to minutes) and long overall runtimes, with some requests timing out (especially via Antigravity CLI or OpenRouter).
- Quantitative benchmarks show Carbon significantly slower than peers:
- ~3× longer to complete tasks, more output tokens and tool calls than opponents in “battle” tests.
- In analytics benchmarks, slower TTFT and more tool calls per question than Hydrogen and others.
- Some see slight recent TTFT improvements, but overall it still ranks among the slowest models tested.
Behavior, Depth, and Quality
- Widely described as “cautious,” “thorough,” and “overly meticulous.”
- Tends to:
- Do extra work not strictly requested (auditing, hardening, edge-case handling).
- Make many tool calls and deep dives into codebases.
- For complex, open-ended coding and research tasks, several users find its solutions surprisingly good, well-architected, and creative—sometimes outperforming rivals.
- Others see this as wasteful overreach that burns tokens and effort budgets, wanting stricter instruction-following instead.
Use Cases and Model Comparisons
- Strong praise for Carbon in: deep RCA, architecture, security/robustness, historical text recognition, and difficult research questions.
- For simpler tasks or interactive workflows, users prefer faster, cheaper models (Hydrogen, Sol, DeepSeek, etc.).
- Some orchestrate Carbon as planner and delegate execution to Hydrogen or other vendors’ models; others argue it should be the opposite.
Infrastructure, Tooling, and UX
- Antigravity and Google tooling are often seen as buggy, slow, and worse for non-Googlers (timeouts, 500 errors, quota exhaustion).
- Some report better behavior via Vertex AI; others find Gemini generally the weakest option they use.
Training, Incentives, and Benchmarks
- Multiple hypotheses:
- Google prioritized frontier quality and bench performance over inference efficiency.
- Test-time scaling / “think longer” variants (e.g., Argon vs Carbon) amplify thoroughness and latency.
- Google’s business model and ample compute let it tolerate inefficiency more than pure-inference businesses.
- There is debate over whether this is deliberate bench-optimizing, a side effect of RL training that rewards exhaustive reasoning, or simply weaker engineering/optimization; no consensus is reached.