Show HN: Cornhole News – A Hacker News inspired site for news across the Midwest
A new Hacker News–style site, Cornhole News, aims to aggregate text-focused stories from across the U.S. Midwest, sparking interest in regional clones for other areas and countries. Commenters debate its reliance on JavaScript, the double-entendre name, and how (or whether) to filter out political content, while suggesting features like state-level filters, RSS feeds, open sourcing, and minimalist, non-tracking monetization. Overall sentiment is positive, especially toward its clean, ad-light design as an alternative to cluttered mainstream news sites.
Overall reception
- Many readers like the clean, HN-style, text-first approach and lack of ads/popups.
- Several express interest in creating similar regional or national versions (e.g., UK, Ireland, other US regions, Canada).
- Some are disappointed it’s not actually about the cornhole game itself.
JavaScript, layout, and UX
- One concern: the page doesn’t render well without JavaScript, which some see as a deal-breaker for an HN-like site where no-JS users are more common.
- Others report it works fine with JS disabled, so behavior may be inconsistent.
- Users dislike that upvoting causes posts to reposition immediately; they want stable ordering until refresh.
- Lack of comment upvoting/replying is noted.
- Bright “light mode” design is visually harsh for some, though others suggest adjusting monitor brightness.
Site name and cultural context
- The term “Cornhole” splits opinion:
- Supporters see it as a playful, very Midwestern reference to the lawn game and even a shibboleth for the target audience.
- Critics object to its longstanding vulgar meaning or find it juvenile, though others respond that prudish users aren’t the target.
Geographic scope and filtering
- Multiple requests for:
- State-level filters (especially for specific states like MN).
- Inclusion or parallel versions for nearby Canadian provinces seen as culturally “Midwestern.”
- Some debate whether “Midwest” is a coherent region, with suggestions to split Great Lakes vs Great Plains or redefine the label.
Politics filter and content classification
- Strong interest in the “politics” toggle, but skepticism it can work cleanly.
- Some argue “everything is political,” implying a non-political news feed would be nearly empty.
- Others push back, saying not all topics are political and that constant politicization reflects broader social dynamics.
- Suggestions include:
- Rules-based definitions (elections, officials, budgets, court cases).
- ML/LLM-based tagging of “current thing” topics.
- HN-style community flagging as a de facto politics filter.
- Consensus: the boundary of “political” content is inherently fuzzy and contentious.
Monetization, openness, and governance
- The creator intends to monetize via small, regionally focused ads and newsletter sponsorships, ideally for profit after a layoff.
- Readers ask whether ads will be self-hosted vs via networks and what moderation policies will be.
- Some ask if the code is open source and how to “steal” or reuse the idea; no clear open-source status is given in-thread.
- Broader meta-discussion about building HN-like communities notes:
- Moderation is hard and expensive.
- Possible roles for AI assistance and transparent mod logs.
- Alternative voting/approval schemes are proposed, though critics say they reduce to up/downvotes.