I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA

US startup immigration remains active but more complex, with rising use of founder- and talent-focused visas like O‑1, E‑2, and self-sponsor H‑1B structures, even as consular scrutiny and processing delays increase. Employment-based green card paths are under pressure: NIW and EB‑1A standards are described as “near-impossible” in many cases, while PERM has become harder for software engineers amid tech layoffs and proposed rule changes that could effectively end the program. Participants also highlight uncertainty around potential six‑figure H‑1B fees, heightened enforcement risks (including for green card holders), and a growing need for careful legal strategy rather than assuming immigration processes are routine.

Startup & Tech Immigration Still Active but Shifting

  • Immigration for startup founders and employees is “still working” but changing; O‑1 and E‑2 usage is up, especially for founders and early employees.
  • Self- or quasi-self-sponsorship paths exist via O‑1, E‑2, and even H‑1B (including concurrent H‑1B/O‑1 for side startups and sole-founder H‑1Bs with careful structuring).
  • For non-US founders, standard options mentioned include O‑1, E‑2, L‑1, and country-specific visas (e.g., TN, H‑1B1, E‑3).

O‑1, EB‑1, NIW & Consular Scrutiny

  • O‑1 approvals at USCIS remain high, but Requests for Evidence (RFEs) and consular pushback at visa interviews have increased.
  • EB‑1A and NIW standards are described as “near-impossible” under current interpretations; many lawyers discourage pursuing them except in exceptional research cases.
  • EB‑1B for researchers is still viable and reportedly seeing good approval rates.
  • Some advice: wait for a potential future change in administration before pursuing EB‑1A/NIW, if possible.

H‑1B, Fees, and Workarounds

  • H‑1B demand continues despite uncertainty about a proposed ~$100K fee; current fee hikes are not in effect but could return.
  • Prior H‑1B status from years ago can often still be reused without the lottery.
  • H‑4 and dependent processing is described as a “disaster” with long waits.
  • Cap-exempt concurrent H‑1Bs allow big-tech employees to found startups without quitting immediately.

PERM, Labor Market, and AI

  • PERM for software engineers is significantly harder due to layoffs and many qualified US applicants, especially for mid-level roles; specialized skills help.
  • Proposed PERM reforms are seen by some as likely to “kill” or end the program rather than fix it.
  • Tension noted between “AI will replace white-collar work” and continued need for H‑1Bs; some argue data on wages and immigrant incomes shows real shortages, others see H‑1Bs as wage suppression.

Processing Delays, Enforcement & Risk

  • N‑400, family-based consular processing, and 221(g) security checks are widely reported as slow, sometimes years long; congressional inquiries and mandamus are limited tools.
  • Post–green-card risk from enforcement is considered higher than before but still low; main advice is to be prepared, have counsel, and carry key documents.
  • ICE and DHS activity are expected to remain largely driven by the executive branch, with only modest oversight shifts.

Role of AI & Tools in Law Practice

  • AI tools are reportedly speeding up analysis and case preparation, though they’re not a substitute for up-to-date legal judgment, especially as standards shift.