Goodbye from Salon
Salon.com, one of the earliest web-native magazines, has announced it is ceasing new publishing after 31 years, prompting mixed reactions ranging from nostalgia to “good riddance.” Commenters recall its early years of strong cultural writing and distinctive voices, but argue it later slid into partisan punditry and SEO-driven clickbait that became interchangeable with countless other outlets. The shutdown is framed as part of a broader collapse in ad-supported media and local journalism, with many noting the rise of Substack, podcasts, and social platforms for opinion writing, and worrying about the long-term impact on independent reporting and democratic accountability.
Immediate reactions
- Mix of indifference, schadenfreude, and real sadness.
- Many hadn’t visited in 10–20 years and assumed it was already gone or a “zombie brand.”
- Some see the shutdown as part of a broader crisis for news; others dismiss Salon as replaceable partisan punditry.
Early Salon vs. later years
- Strong nostalgia for late‑90s / early‑2000s Salon: distinctive columns, culture writing, tech obits, and an unusually clean UI.
- People remember forums and personals as important early‑web communities; abrupt forum deletion left lasting bitterness.
- Several say tone shifted over time toward negativity, clickbait, and hyper‑partisan or identity‑driven opinion pieces.
Perceived causes of decline
- Editorial: loss of “unique voice,” overreliance on predictable ideological takes and punditry rather than reporting.
- Economics: ad‑saturated pages, broad paywalling, and friction-heavy subscription and cancellation flows deterred paying users.
- Data practices: belief that management prioritized data collection and resale over reader experience.
- Ownership: described as a “zombie SEO play” after past acquisitions; footer affiliate spam cited as evidence.
Platform, SEO, and AI dynamics
- Many blame Google: sites optimized for SEO only to have search and AI overviews cannibalize traffic.
- Ad blockers seen by some as a factor, but others argue the deeper issue is collapsing ad economics and Google/Facebook dominance.
- Thread notes that generic explainer content is especially vulnerable now that LLM summaries exist.
Journalism vs. punditry
- Multiple commenters stress Salon never had much of a traditional newsroom; mostly commentary and cultural criticism.
- Broader debate about the collapse of “beat” reporting, foreign/local bureaus, and the shift to opinion and aggregation.
- Some argue people now lack media literacy and gravitate to ragebait; others say audiences simply prefer different formats.
Where things move next
- Many mention Substack, podcasts, YouTube, and social media as the new home for independent commentary.
- Concern that these platforms rarely fund original reporting and often lack editors, leading to low rigor and more propaganda.
- Several urge readers to support remaining independent or local outlets and to preserve Salon’s archives via web archives or downloads.