Semi-transparent, colored cadmium telluride photovoltaic panels in agrivoltaics
Semi-transparent magenta cadmium telluride solar panels that pass plant‑useful light while harvesting the rest are prompting renewed interest in “agrivoltaics,” where crops and photovoltaics share the same land. Commenters weigh the technical and economic trade-offs against conventional full-spectrum panels plus LEDs, as well as practical issues like machinery clearance, irrigation, plant shading needs, and long‑term soil and zoning concerns. Many see the biggest near‑term promise in greenhouses, shade‑tolerant or high‑value crops, and dual‑use grazing systems, while others argue that abundant non-arable land and parking lots still make dedicated solar fields the simpler large‑scale solution.
Greenhouse applications and plant response
- Many see wavelength‑selective, magenta CdTe panels as ideal for greenhouses: they provide shade where insolation is excessive, reduce heat and water loss, and generate power.
- Growers note many crops (leafy greens, flowers, strawberries, tomatoes, cucumbers, pumpkins) benefit from partial shade and diffuse light; direct sun can cause “wilting” stress and slower growth.
- The cited broccoli study: slower time to harvest but similar yields, substantially higher biomass under shade, improved water-status metrics, and slightly altered macro/micronutrient profiles.
- Debate over plant biology: some argue plants mainly use red/blue, reflecting green as “waste”; others warn biology often finds uses for “ignored” wavelengths and current understanding may be incomplete.
- Several point out many crops are CO₂- rather than light‑limited, so capturing “unused” wavelengths for electricity may not significantly hurt yields in many cases.
Physics and spectrum selectivity
- Commenters are enthusiastic about spectrum engineering: combining materials to harvest certain bands, leaving photosynthetically useful light, and potentially managing thermal radiation (e.g., reflecting short‑wave IR while maximizing emission in atmospheric IR windows).
- Some suggest dual roles in deserts: electricity plus radiative cooling, though others note this is challenging and requires clear skies.
Economics and competing system designs
- One camp argues: standard high‑efficiency panels plus targeted LEDs inside greenhouses are likely cheaper and more flexible than custom semi‑transparent PV.
- Counterpoints: plant lighting demands are huge; converting sunlight to electricity and back to photons via LEDs is energetically and economically costly.
- Skepticism that specialty agrivoltaic panels can match the cost trajectory of commodity PV; translucent modules would need dramatic price drops to be competitive.
Land use, machinery, and scale
- Some say agrivoltaics mainly makes sense where land is scarce or high‑value (e.g., greenhouses, specialty crops, flower farms, market gardens) or with manual/mechanized small tools.
- Large mechanized row-crop operations (corn, hay, alfalfa, cotton) face clearance and layout issues: combines, sprayer booms, and especially center‑pivot irrigation demand tall, wide‑span, obstruction‑free fields. Raising panels high enough would greatly increase structural cost.
- Grazing under panels (sheep, cattle) is seen as already practical in some regions, reducing mowing costs and offering shade; but panel height, robustness, and access for haying equipment are constraints.
- Some regions strictly zone prime farmland for agriculture; dual‑use agrivoltaics is seen as a possible regulatory path where pure solar fields are blocked. Others emphasize there is abundant marginal or non‑arable land for solar, plus rooftops and parking lots.
Materials, toxicity, and tellurium supply
- CdTe toxicity is a concern, but supporters note the cadmium compound is encapsulated between glass layers.
- Discussion on tellurium scarcity: it’s geologically rare and mostly an inexpensive byproduct of copper refining, limiting CdTe scaling to roughly tens of GW/year in the near term.
- Some speculate about space mining tellurium; others deem it uneconomic and highlight that if space mining existed, it would target higher‑value metals first.
- Long subthread debates whether space‑mining logistics could be weaponized for kinetic strikes; consensus among several participants is that this is far less practical or impactful than existing nuclear and conventional options, while one participant remains worried.
Corn ethanol vs solar energy
- Multiple comments highlight the inefficiency of corn‑to‑ethanol as an energy pathway; a large fraction (roughly a third to ~40%) of US corn is used for ethanol.
- Cited work (and back‑of‑envelope calculations) suggest solar PV can yield on the order of 30× more usable energy per acre than corn ethanol, and much more once ICE inefficiency is factored in.
- Some argue ethanol exists less for energy efficiency and more to keep farmland and farmer capacity “on standby” for potential future food shortages; critics respond that current practices degrade soil and that subsidies distort land use.
- Economic comparisons: rough figures suggest an Ohio corn acre might net a few hundred dollars in profit per year, whereas a solar installation or lease on that acre could yield an order of magnitude more revenue, though grid‑connection and capital costs are significant and region‑specific.
Grid, storage, and off‑grid trends
- Storage and transmission are recurring concerns: moving electricity from rural solar to demand centers and storing intermittent power is non‑trivial and costly, but commenters contrast this with the logistical overhead and inefficiency of producing, hauling, and burning ethanol.
- Some emphasize distributed, small‑scale solar plus batteries (including on RVs and homesteads) as a growing trend for resilience and independence, reducing reliance on centralized grid infrastructure.
- Others argue large utility‑scale solar is still needed for cities and industry, and that single‑site attacks or failures are relatively unimportant at grid scale compared with high‑voltage substations.
Institutional and social factors
- A small commercial flower grower reports USDA skepticism toward agrivoltaics based on prior negative experiences with solar companies and concerns about creeping industrialization of farmland and future rezoning.
- Suggestions include cooperative ownership structures so farmers retain control and avoid becoming de facto land providers for external energy firms.
- Some commenters question the premise that farmland is scarce at all, especially in the US, arguing that land, not light, is rarely the bottleneck for food, and that traditional greenhouses and simple shade structures may remain cheaper than complex agrivoltaic systems in many contexts.