Going back two years on Hacker News is like entering another, better universe
Many long-time Hacker News readers feel the site has been transformed by an overwhelming surge of AI-related posts, bot-generated content, and a sharper, more cynical tone. Commenters debate whether this reflects broader shifts in the tech industry and internet culture—such as hype cycles, enshittification, and social-media-style outrage—or simply the inevitable “Eternal September” of any growing community. Some propose technical fixes, alternative sites, or invite-only spaces, while others argue HN still offers unusually high-quality, human conversation amid a noisier web.
Perceived AI Saturation
- Many feel AI has flooded HN: “almost everything” in new submissions and a large share of front-page items over the last 1–2 years.
- Others say the main page still has a reasonable mix (e.g., only ~5/25 AI posts on some days) and see this as normal for a transformative technology.
- Comparisons are made to past hype cycles (crypto, NoSQL, blockchain, Docker, Ruby/Go), but several argue AI dominance is on a different scale, backed by popularity queries.
Filtering, Tags, and Workarounds
- Proposals include AI-specific tags (like “Show HN”), or even a dedicated AI-only site.
- Users mention tools to strip AI topics (e.g., unslop.news, browser extensions to auto-hide AI headlines, personal filters hiding 100–200 posts/day).
- Tagging is seen as helpful by some, but others cite experiences on other sites where tags fueled drama, witch-hunts, and fragmentation.
Bots, LLMs, and Authenticity
- Widespread concern that AI-generated posts, comments, and “slop” are drowning out human voices on HN, Reddit, Twitter/X, and GitHub.
- Some fear a future where open forums are unusable without heavy bot filtering or moving to invite-only spaces (Discord, Signal, Telegram).
- Ideas to verify human authorship (e.g., PGP-signed posts, BOT labels) are criticized as impractical, elitist, or easily gamed via copy‑pasted LLM text.
- A subset finds the fixation on “was this written by AI?” itself exhausting and unproductive.
Negativity, Culture Shift, and Politics
- Many report more spite, “empty sneering,” and hostile pile‑ons; some say HN now leaves them angry, similar to why they left Reddit.
- Others insist politics remains relatively rare and that AI, not politics, dominates.
- Several tie rising negativity to broader societal trends: loss of techno‑optimism after ~2016, “enshittification” of platforms, economic and political stress, and tech’s role in oppression rather than empowerment.
Moderation, Community Trajectory, and Counterpoints
- Moderation is both praised as uniquely good and criticized as inflexible, slow to adapt, and sometimes overzealous with flags.
- Some argue HN hit an “Eternal September” a few years ago; others note that complaints about decline and “turning into Reddit” have recurred for well over a decade.
- Despite issues, many still see HN as one of the last mostly bot‑free, high‑signal tech forums, especially in niche or highly technical threads, on weekends, and outside US peak hours.