Queens Public Library under ransomware attack

A ransomware attack has disrupted many online services at Queens Public Library, highlighting how vulnerable public and nonprofit institutions are to cybercrime despite having limited funds. Commenters debate whether such targets are chosen deliberately or hit opportunistically, discuss the role of phishing, software vulnerabilities, and cyber-insurance in enabling ransomware, and compare similar incidents at libraries in other cities and countries. Many express concern that recovery can take months or years, especially when legacy systems and incomplete backups are involved.

Perception of Targeting a Public Library

  • Many see a public library as a “terrible” and morally repugnant target given limited budgets and social value.
  • Some argue attacks are likely untargeted/indiscriminate rather than focused specifically on libraries.
  • A few comments use dark humor (e.g., “erase the debts” like Fight Club, “encrypted on paper”) to cope with the absurdity.

Ransomware Operations and Insurance

  • Ransomware groups are described as operating at scale with low marginal cost: encrypt first, negotiate later.
  • Several mention “customer support” from ransomware operators, including trial decryption to build trust.
  • Cyber-insurance is reported as a major factor: attackers may care less about the victim’s wealth if insurers often pay.
  • One anecdote describes an insurer casually recognizing a “reputable” ransomware group, shocking the victim.
  • Some see ransom insurance as exacerbating the problem rather than solving it.

Likely Attack Vectors

  • One commenter speculates about a recent PHP vulnerability; others say ransomware more often starts with phishing than web app exploits.
  • Multiple recent vulnerabilities and tools (e.g., SSH-related) are mentioned as possible alternatives; root cause is unclear.
  • There is speculation that largely automated or even AI-based agents could now be probing and exploiting systems.

Recovery, Backups, and Operational Challenges

  • Suggestions to “wipe and start again” are challenged as unrealistic for a large catalog (millions of items).
  • Rebuilding from scratch is estimated to take many years of manual data entry.
  • Online or poorly isolated backups are criticized; if connected, they can also be encrypted.
  • Legacy, unmaintained systems can greatly extend recovery time, as seen in other libraries.

Experiences from Other Library Systems

  • Seattle, Toronto, Westmount (Montréal), Delaware, Calgary, and the British Library are cited as past ransomware victims.
  • Common impacts: months-long outages of computers, Wi‑Fi, and some services.
  • Some systems reportedly did not pay ransoms, instead restoring slowly or using honor-based lending during outages.
  • The British Library is noted as still not fully recovered years later.

NYC Library System Structure and Access

  • Thread digresses into NYC’s three independent systems (Queens, Brooklyn, NYPL) and the need for multiple cards.
  • Users note advantages for e-book availability and borrowing limits across systems.
  • New York State residents can often get cards for multiple systems; some mention Buffalo as well.
  • Queens reportedly offers a paid worldwide membership for digital access, which some find ironically discovered via this incident.