Scientists claim the universe is twice as old as believed
Claims that the universe might be around 26–27 billion years old — roughly twice the standard 13.8 billion — prompt sharp skepticism, with multiple commenters noting the lack of broad scientific acceptance and pointing to peer‑reviewed work that contradicts the idea. Much of the exchange centers on how cosmological models are validated, the role and limits of peer review, and why mainstream estimates of the universe’s age have actually shifted only slightly in recent decades. Participants also branch into related topics such as the Hubble tension, whether time and the universe can meaningfully be said to have a beginning, and common misconceptions about the Big Bang.
Scientific credibility and peer review
- Several commenters ask whether the “twice as old” universe claim appears in reputable, peer‑reviewed journals; a specific MNRAS paper is linked.
- Some insist that without peer review it “isn’t science”; others argue peer review is a helpful filter but not an ultimate arbiter, stressing individual critical evaluation.
- There is criticism of treating peer review as a “committee of truth keepers” and concern that “science” can become socially policed or cult‑like.
Status of the 27‑billion‑year claim
- Multiple earlier HN threads on this model are cited; commenters say the result is not regarded as credible and is near “crackpot” territory.
- A popular-science critique describing the claim as “extremely unlikely” is linked, as is a possible falsification paper.
- Commenters emphasize that mainstream estimates of the universe’s age have shifted only modestly over decades, not by factors of two.
Big Bang, age of the universe, and infinity
- Some participants prefer an “ageless” or eternal universe, arguing that “everything” cannot come from nothing.
- Others like models where infinities do not exist, implying a beginning in some sense.
- Clarifications: “age of the universe” in cosmology typically means time since the Big Bang of our observable spacetime, not necessarily “everything that exists.”
- Alternatives and hunches raised include cyclic cosmologies, timescape cosmology (non-uniform time), and “inside a black hole” scenarios, but these are speculative in the thread.
Time, consciousness, and philosophy
- Several digressions discuss time as illusion vs perception, and whether spacetime is fundamental or derivative of consciousness.
- Infinite regress in “what created the universe/creator/simulation” is noted; some suggest existence might be the “default condition.”
- The difficulty and emotional weight of contemplating origins (and cyclic or infinite models) is frequently acknowledged.
Fundamental constants and numerology
- A claim about re-expressing constants so most are
1, with exceptions for universe age (10⁴⁰) and gravity (~10⁻⁴⁰), is discussed. - Others respond that this is mostly unit choice and not inherently meaningful; natural units and Dirac’s large-number ideas are mentioned.
- There is an extended technical exchange on what counts as a fundamental constant vs fundamental unit, and on the role of metrology.
Fermi paradox and reactions
- A much older universe is seen as worsening “where is everyone?”; one answer is that civilizations are dead or constrained by physics.
- Some commenters respond with humor about constantly updating beliefs as cosmological estimates change.
Pop-culture tangent
- The Big Bang Theory TV show prompts a side discussion about laugh tracks, generational tastes, and nostalgia for classic sitcoms versus more immersive modern shows.