Minnesota guitarist's "palmfrets" invention strikes a new chord

A Minnesota inventor’s “palmfrets” device mounts extra frets at the bridge of a guitar, letting the picking hand raise the pitch of the bass strings and play simultaneous bass lines and higher melodies. Commenters see creative potential for solo and chord‑melody work, especially on electric instruments, but raise concerns about intonation, ergonomics, lost upper frets, and how dependent players might become on hardware that won’t exist on most guitars. Many compare it to capos, tremolo systems, and multi‑bender bridges, concluding it is an interesting niche innovation rather than a revolution in guitar design.

What palmfrets is and how it works

  • Device mounts near the bridge, under the low (bass) strings only.
  • Acts like “extra frets” at the bridge side: pressing with the picking-hand palm shortens the string by 1–3 semitones.
  • Main goal: play low bass notes (often open-string equivalents) while the fretting hand stays high up the neck for melody or chord voicings.
  • Several commenters characterize it as a dynamic, selective mini-capo for bass strings, controlled by the right hand.

Musical possibilities and limits

  • Potentially useful for:
    • Simultaneous bass and melody or chord-melody jazz voicings.
    • Drone notes and richer harmony when fingerpicking.
    • Players with smaller hands who can’t comfortably reach low bass notes while fretting high.
  • Limited because:
    • Only affects bass strings and a small pitch range.
    • Alternate tunings, capos, extra strings, or established hardware (benders, TransTrem, whammy/tremolo plus pitch-shift pedals) already cover nearby territory.
    • Using a palm fret and a neck fret on the same string would be out of tune; intonation math also makes microtonal/quarter-tone use largely impractical.

Ergonomics and interference with normal technique

  • Concerns about:
    • Awkward wrist angle and possible RSI, especially for players who aim for more neutral hand posture.
    • Interference with palm muting; a heavier mute could accidentally trigger a clear fretted note.
    • Prototype removes the bridge pickup and upper frets, which many view as unacceptable compromises.
    • Demo videos noted for buzzing and questions about how well the system integrates on acoustics without harming tone.

Adoption prospects and broader philosophy

  • Some see it as a neat niche tool they’d buy or clone for a “parts” guitar.
  • Others dismiss it as a gimmick offering little musical gain versus its trade-offs; they doubt major manufacturers will adopt it.
  • Broader debate:
    • One side values modifying instruments and “drawing your own line” to unlock new ideas.
    • The other stresses constraints, standardization, and transferable technique, warning that specialized hardware can lock compositions to a single customized guitar.