Monkey Island: all 13 versions side by side

A retro web project showcases 13 different platform versions of the classic adventure game *The Secret of Monkey Island* side by side, highlighting how its art and audio were adapted across CGA, EGA, VGA, Amiga, Mac, Sega CD, and more. Commenters delve into the technical and artistic constraints of early PC and console graphics—limited color palettes, sound hardware, and copy protection schemes—and how these limitations drove creative solutions. Many reflect on the enduring charm of the EGA and Amiga versions, the evolution of adventure game design, and the strong nostalgia these games still evoke.

Overall reaction & site design

  • Strongly positive response to the comparison site; many call it beautiful, nostalgic, and praise the Turbo Vision / DOS-style UI and mobile support.
  • Several note it feels like a perfectly fitting UX for this subject.
  • Some point out it’s “not all” versions (e.g., at least the anniversary re-release and some older platforms like C64/Apple II aren’t represented).

Graphics, ports, and color palettes

  • Discussion that there are essentially two main art sets (EGA and VGA); other versions are mostly derived via downsampling, dithering, or palette adjustments.
  • Amiga version impresses people by getting very close to VGA quality with only 32 colors, though it often doesn’t even use the full palette; speculation that space/compression or GUI needs drove that.
  • Atari ST version is widely seen as weaker, closer to EGA than VGA.
  • Mac version’s appearance leads to observations about historical gamma differences.
  • Many reminisce about CGA, EGA, Hercules, composite tricks, and scanline/palette hacks, with a split between “CGA was awful” and “CGA done well could look great.”
  • Debate over which version “looks best”: common favorites are VGA, Amiga, and EGA, with several arguing that the bold, constrained EGA art is artistically superior to or at least as strong as VGA.

Audio and sound hardware

  • People recall the effort put into PC speaker music versus higher-end sound cards and MIDI/FM hardware.
  • Links to recordings of the theme on different hardware are suggested as a way to remember which version one played.

Nostalgia and game design

  • Heavy nostalgia for Monkey Island and contemporary adventure games (LucasArts, Sierra, others).
  • Some argue the puzzles/gameplay aged poorly compared to later Japanese puzzle/adventure series; others say they were appropriately challenging for the era.
  • Long subthread of recommendations for modern games that capture a similar sense of discovery or narrative puzzle-solving (e.g., Obra Dinn, Golden Idol, various indie adventures).

Constraints and creativity

  • Multiple comments reflect on how strict technical limits (color count, storage, hardware) forced creativity in art, audio, and design.
  • Broader discussion that constraints can improve design and originality, contrasted with today’s “excess” enabling cluttered UIs and less disciplined decisions.