Crows make decisions faster than we can
New research on crows’ rapid decision‑making is prompting renewed scrutiny of the “birdbrain” stereotype and broader assumptions about animal intelligence. Commenters highlight how avian brains achieve high information-processing capacity through dense, efficient neural architectures, enabling feats like complex navigation, social behavior and problem‑solving that in some cases rival primates. The thread widens into a debate over how to define and measure intelligence across species, the role of evolution and ecological niches, and whether humans are as uniquely “special” as we tend to believe.
Meaning of “birdbrain” and article framing
- Many argue the title is misleading: “birdbrain” colloquially means “stupid,” not “slow.”
- Several note you can be both quick and foolish; fast processing doesn’t refute the insult’s usual meaning.
- Some think the article is attacking a straw man and over-selling a “small brain = fast” angle.
Avian brains: size, structure, and efficiency
- Multiple comments emphasize brain size is a poor proxy for intelligence.
- Corvids and some parrots have very high neuron density and different wiring from mammals, yielding high “information processing capacity” in small volumes.
- Bird neurons are said to be shorter, more densely packed, and more energy‑efficient than mammalian ones, possibly enabling faster processing.
- There’s curiosity about trade‑offs: metabolic cost, learning speed, or limits that might come with extreme miniaturization.
Decision speed, reaction time, and flight
- Commenters link fast decisions to flight demands: birds navigate cluttered environments at high speed, land on tiny branches, and perform complex aerobatics.
- Some push back that humans also handle high speeds (cars, bikes), but others note this is evolutionarily recent and we redesign environments (sign spacing, road design) to accommodate slower cognition.
- A few highlight that fast decisions may be reflexive rather than “thoughtful,” and that the experiment measured performance on a specific task, not general intelligence.
Intelligence across species
- Corvids, parrots, and some other birds are widely praised as problem solvers, tool users, and social learners; anecdotes include crows mimicking words and using human cues.
- Chickens, pigeons, turkeys, and doves are often called “stupid,” though some note domestication and niche adaptation complicate that judgment and chickens have notable social intelligence.
- Broader discussion touches on convergent evolution of intelligence (mammals, birds, octopuses; sometimes insects like bees) and the idea that many forms of “intelligence” exist along a continuum.
Human exceptionalism vs humility
- One camp stresses humans are clearly “special” given our technological and civilizational impact.
- Another argues humans overrate themselves and underrate other animals, which survive in harsh environments where many humans would quickly fail.
- Several note that cooperation, language, and external memory (writing, media) make human intelligence qualitatively different, even if not the only kind.
Learning, motor control, and neural architecture
- Debate over whether skilled actions (piano, dance) are mainly “trained spine,” cerebellum, or predictive brain models; consensus is that multiple levels of the nervous system are involved.
- Some draw an analogy: central brain as “general,” peripheral and spinal circuits as “sergeants” executing well‑learned patterns with low latency.