Many of Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday “deals” offered no savings

An investigation finding that many of Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday “deals” offered no real savings prompted broader scrutiny of how retailers manipulate prices and strikethrough discounts. Commenters describe tactics such as raising prices before sales, opaque search and ad placement, fake scarcity, and low-quality third‑party products, while pointing to price‑tracking tools and EU/Canadian rules on reference pricing as partial safeguards. The exchange reflects a wider loss of trust in Amazon’s marketplace and “sale” culture in general, alongside pragmatic advice to compare prices, check history, and not assume major event discounts are genuine bargains.

Scope of “fake deals” and how bad it is

  • Many say this isn’t unique to Amazon; it’s a standard retail tactic (Macy’s, Walmart rollbacks, liquidation sales, AliExpress/Temu events, tourist-town shops, etc.).
  • Common pattern: raise prices weeks before a sale, then “discount” back to the previous normal price.
  • Some commenters think the report is less damning than framed: if ~2/3 of deals are cheaper and ~9/10 aren’t worse, they expected worse.
  • Others argue even ~10% fake or worse‑than‑normal “deals” is unacceptable and should be 0, especially when used to trigger purchases that wouldn’t otherwise happen.

Law, regulation, and gaming the rules

  • Multiple jurisdictions already restrict fake markdowns:
    • EU Omnibus Directive: advertised discounts must reference the lowest price in the last 30 days; similar rules noted in France, UK, Canada, and FTC guidance in the US.
  • Several point out enforcement is weak, and retailers game 30‑day rules by hiking prices a month+ before big events.
  • Some propose stronger rules: e.g., base discounts on 52‑week median or show 1‑year low; others note model/SKU churn used to dodge history.

Tools and tactics consumers use

  • Frequent recommendations: CamelCamelCamel, Keepa, other price‑tracking sites, and Amazon’s own 30/90/365‑day price history.
  • Some distrust depending on Amazon’s APIs and data, but comparisons suggest Amazon’s history is generally accurate (though often only for Amazon‑sold items).
  • Strategies: wishlist + wait for true dips, cross‑shop other retailers, use price alerts, ignore “sale” language and look only at actual price.

Amazon search, marketplace quality, and trust

  • Complaints: search sorted by price hides better options behind ads, “Prime only” filters, and dark patterns; AI search sometimes forced; throttled search reported by some.
  • Strong sentiment that reviews are unreliable (fake, incentivized, unverified purchasers allowed) and many brands are low‑quality, opaque OEMs.
  • Some say Amazon has “burned” customer trust, prioritizing its bottom line over its stated principles; others still value its logistics and customer service highly.

Prime, convenience, and behavior change

  • Many report canceling Prime drastically reduced impulse buying and overall spend.
  • Others remain because of fast/easy shipping and frictionless returns, especially with kids or in areas where alternatives are worse.
  • Broader reflection that “sale” culture exploits psychological desire to feel like we got a deal, not necessarily to deliver real savings.