Mem Is Shutting Down
An AI-powered note-taking startup, Mem, is shutting down after raising roughly $29 million in venture funding, prompting questions about the viability of VC-backed productivity apps in an already saturated notes market. Commenters contrast Mem’s fate with leaner, often open-source or markdown-based tools like Obsidian, Joplin, and org-mode, arguing that durable file formats, local storage, and modest ambitions may be more sustainable than heavily funded cloud services. More broadly, the conversation reflects skepticism that AI-assisted note-taking and summarization can stand alone as businesses when similar capabilities are being built directly into major AI platforms.
Reaction to Mem Shutting Down
- Many commenters were unaware Mem still existed; some are unsurprised it’s closing.
- Shutdown is seen as relatively graceful: 60‑day export window and migration guides are appreciated.
- Some question why the service can’t be kept read‑only indefinitely “since it’s just notes.”
- A few express sympathy for the team and note they attempted something genuinely new.
VC Funding and Startup Economics
- The $29M raised is repeatedly highlighted; some view this as emblematic of a “brainless” investor ecosystem in a saturated space.
- Others argue this is normal VC strategy: many small bets, most go to zero, a few pay for the rest.
- Clarifications: funding is equity, not debt; often paid in tranches or credits; investors may recover remaining cash in liquidation.
- There’s disagreement on VC as an asset class: some say one jackpot offsets failures; others cite data claiming overall returns are poor.
- Ethically, some see “duping VCs” as minor compared with other systemic harms; others push back, emphasizing personal responsibility.
Note‑Taking App Landscape & Alternatives
- Multiple alternatives are discussed: Obsidian, Standard Notes, Joplin, org‑mode, Apple Notes, various self‑hosted and markdown‑based tools.
- Strong preference from many for plain files (often Markdown) and directory structures over proprietary databases.
- Joplin draws both praise (E2E encryption, uses existing cloud storage, plugins) and criticism (stores content in SQLite with UUIDs, “fenced garden” feel).
- Some insist a basic editor + filesystem + git is sufficient; others want richer UX, plugins, and AI features.
AI, Notes, and “File over App”
- Several argue AI‑enhanced note‑taking and summarization are low‑value or non‑defensible as standalone businesses, since core AI providers now offer similar features.
- Others counter that summarization and ingestion of messy data is exactly what makes base AI apps “killer” and productive.
- Idea emerges that separate note apps may fade as agents gain long‑term memory and RAG over personal data.
- “File over app” philosophy is endorsed: apps are ephemeral, but durable, open formats like Markdown are more future‑proof, especially with LLMs.
UX, Performance, and Sync Debates
- Obsidian is both recommended and criticized:
- Pros: strong UI for many, fast in practice according to some, powerful plugin ecosystem, markdown files on disk.
- Cons: runs on Electron (accused of being heavy and memory‑hungry), perceived sluggishness for some users and benchmarks, high RAM usage for “just notes.”
- Sync is contentious:
- Some say using plain file sync (iCloud/Drive/etc.) is trivial and adequate.
- Others describe complex steps to self‑host full‑feature/live sync (e.g., CouchDB + plugins) and see this friction as near “intentional sabotage” to push paid cloud sync.
- Defenders argue the team is small, can’t support every sync model, and focuses on core app while community provides many options.
Small Business and Productivity Angle
- Several commenters note that SMB owners care less about “AI” per se and more about concrete time and cost savings.
- Examples cited: automating normalization of multiple inspection reports into tasks and readable summaries; potential automated outreach for salons.
- Consensus: tools must deliver clear productivity gains, not just AI branding or new note‑taking paradigms.