Librem 5 v2

Purism’s crowdfunded Librem 5 v2, a $1,599 RISC‑V “privacy phone” running mainline Linux, is pitched as a device you can truly own and audit, with features like hardware kill switches and a smart card reader. Commenters question its value given dated specs, weak camera and browser performance, limited app availability (especially banking and 2FA), and an estimated 2028 delivery, noting it functions more as a niche, open‑hardware experiment than a practical daily driver. The project also revives concerns about Purism’s previous Librem 5 campaign, including long delays, refund disputes, and whether small-batch economics can sustain a competitive, trustworthy alternative to iOS and Android.

Product positioning and timeline

  • Many commenters object to calling this a “launch”; it’s a crowdfunding campaign with delivery projected around 2028, and Purism’s past Librem 5 delays are frequently cited.
  • Some see it primarily as a niche developer tool or “computer you truly own and trust,” not a mass‑market phone.

Price, specs, and value

  • $1,599 price is widely criticized: seen as “flagship price, mid‑tier (or worse) specs.”
  • Complaints include weak CPU, modest 13MP camera, and re‑used chassis; some expect sub‑optimal 5G if added later.
  • Others argue small-batch, privacy‑focused hardware will always be expensive; mainstream phones benefit from economies of scale and service cross‑subsidies.

Openness, security, and threat models

  • Supporters emphasize open hardware/firmware, separation of baseband, kill switches, smartcard reader, and a system not controlled by Google/Apple.
  • Critics counter that Android (especially AOSP/GrapheneOS) already provides strong security models and hardware isolation, and that RISC‑V SoC lacks some modern security features.
  • Debate over how much “trust” open source really guarantees.

RISC‑V performance and software ecosystem

  • Several point out the chosen SpacemiT K1 is roughly comparable to very old ARM “little cores,” with particularly poor single‑core performance.
  • Concerns that web browsing and JS-heavy workloads will feel laggy; RISC‑V browser/JIT support is described as immature.
  • App availability is questioned: many Flatpaks and apps like Signal are x86_64‑only; emulation and ARM64 support are seen as unproven.

Banking, apps, and day‑to‑day usability

  • Strong tension between ideals and practicality:
    • Some users already live without proprietary banking/2FA apps and choose banks/services accordingly.
    • Others say in parts of the EU and elsewhere banking is increasingly tied to Android/iOS apps, reducing real choice.
  • Lack of mainstream app stores and some enterprise tools (e.g., Cisco Duo) is a blocker for many.
  • Power management and push-notification reliability (e.g., XMPP) are raised as critical for real‑world use.

Company behavior and trust

  • Several posts describe negative experiences from the original Librem 5 campaign: long delays, changing/refusing refunds, offering store credit instead of money, and marketing claims later softened.
  • Defenders argue the company was near insolvency and has now made conditions explicit (no refunds); critics describe this as still unethical or “shady.”
  • Allegations of questionable use of company funds are mentioned but not substantiated within the thread (noted as “check the 1099s”).

Alternatives and ecosystem

  • Alternatives discussed: GrapheneOS on Pixels or Motorola “secure” phones, Fairphone 5/6 with Android or postmarketOS/Nura, legacy PinePhone, and other Linux phone projects (e.g., Furi).
  • Some praise Purism’s role in advancing mainline Linux on phones but prefer more mature, cheaper, or better‑specced options for daily driving.