We need smart people who give a shit
Many commenters argue that complex systems are becoming more fragile because organizations increasingly prioritize speed, metrics, and AI‑generated output over deep expertise and genuine care for quality. Engineers and other professionals who “give a shit” report being sidelined, burned out, or punished for raising concerns, while short‑term incentives reward visible velocity, politics, and sloppier practices. Others counter that failures can still arise despite competent, caring people, and point to structural management and incentive problems—rather than AI alone—as the root cause, especially in large, KPI‑driven companies.
Role of “smart people who give a shit”
- Many agree complex systems depend on technically competent people who care about reliability, users, and long‑term consequences.
- Several say such people are increasingly sidelined: they slow “velocity,” insist on quality, raise uncomfortable risks, and thus are seen as blockers.
- Others push back, saying these people are still prized in high‑impact teams and that caring + competence is heavily rewarded in the right orgs.
Organizational incentives & management
- Strong theme: incentives favor visibility, speed, and ladder‑climbing over craftsmanship, maintenance, and thoughtful dissent.
- “Giving a shit” is often punished via poor reviews, layoffs, or “not a culture fit” labels; firefighters get praise, preventers are invisible.
- Some see management as overloaded onto engineers; others argue good, focused management is crucial and often missing.
- Hierarchies and KPI/OKR cultures tend to optimize for metrics (PR counts, new features) rather than durable systems or user experience.
AI, “slop,” and code quality
- Many fear AI accelerates “slop”: more code, less understanding, and “comprehension debt.” AI can patch symptoms and over‑engineer, hiding fragility.
- Some report being forced to use agents, supervise multiple AI sessions, or replace QA with AI, which they feel degrades quality and satisfaction.
- Others argue AI can greatly amplify caring engineers, enabling more refactoring, testing, and side‑quest fixes if used judiciously.
- There’s disagreement on whether current outages are meaningfully linked to AI; several call the “AI caused this” narrative speculative.
Capitalism, labor, and reward structures
- Widespread sentiment that contemporary capitalism under‑rewards people who care and over‑rewards short‑term financial optimization.
- Some argue the core problem is financialization and PE‑style hollowing‑out, not “capitalism” per se; others say capitalism itself is the misaligned “stove.”
- A minority defend capitalism/meritocracy as broadly effective and see the article’s framing as ideological overreach.
Reliability, complexity, and outages
- Commenters contrast older engineered systems (e.g., telephony) designed for no single point of failure with today’s brittle, centralized, outsourced stacks.
- Management is blamed for under‑investing in robustness, redundancy, and tech‑debt repayment because prevention is hard to measure and doesn’t sell.
Personal responses and burnout
- Many recount burning out or “quiet quitting” after realizing extra effort mostly benefits managers or shareholders, not themselves.
- Common coping advice: align what you care about with what the business values, pick orgs and managers that genuinely reward quality, or exit to consulting/independent work.
- Some pessimistically conclude that, in current conditions, it is rational for smart people not to give a shit.