Carnival Cruises emits ten times more sulphur oxide than all of Europe's cars (2019)

Carnival’s sulphur oxide emissions, claimed in a 2019 study to exceed those of all Europe’s cars, prompt broader scrutiny of how cruise and cargo ships burn cheap “bunker fuel” and shift pollution from air to sea via scrubbers. Commenters contrast the essential role of container shipping with the purely recreational nature of cruises, debating whether banning or heavily taxing cruise fuel would be a “low‑hanging fruit” for climate policy. Others note that post‑2020 IMO sulphur limits and emerging LNG‑powered ships have changed the landscape, and tie the issue into larger questions about geoengineering, aerosol-induced cloud cover, and whether regulatory efforts unfairly target everyday car users over large industrial emitters.

Bunker Fuel and Shipping Emissions

  • Large ships (cruise, container, tankers) commonly burn heavy fuel oil (“bunker fuel”) — the dirtiest refinery residue, high in sulfur, viscous, and needing heated tanks.
  • Commenters note this has been known for decades; big ships are optimized for ultra‑cheap fuel and low cost per km.
  • Many argue container shipping is tolerated because it underpins global trade, whereas cruises are seen as optional leisure.

Cruises: Luxury, Demographics, and Labor

  • Debate over whether cruises are for “rich old people” or mass‑market middle class; recent data cited showing growing Millennial/Gen Z share.
  • Carnival is described as budget/mid‑market, not luxury; there are smaller luxury lines.
  • Cruise ships provide thousands of relatively low‑wage working‑class jobs per vessel; some compare them to “affordable” vacations vs yachts for the truly rich.

Sulfur Rules, Scrubbers, and Environmental Tradeoffs

  • Pre‑2020, sulfur emissions from ships were very high; IMO 2020 sharply lowered allowed sulfur in fuel.
  • Responses included switching fuels near coasts and using scrubbers; open‑loop scrubbers shift pollution from air to sea, drawing criticism.
  • LNG‑powered ships and shore power at ports are cited as partial improvements.

Aerosols, Cloud Cover, and Geoengineering

  • Several comments discuss how sulfur aerosols seed clouds and cool the planet (aerosol masking / global dimming).
  • Some claim the 2020 sulfur cuts in shipping may have significantly increased the recent warming rate; others link work suggesting little net radiative change, highlighting scientific uncertainty.
  • Ideas floated: marine cloud brightening via sea‑salt spray, aerosol additives for jets, iron fertilization, solar shades in space; strong concern about unknown side effects vs urgency of climate risks.

Policy Ideas and Enforcement Challenges

  • Proposals: ban bunker fuel for recreational ships, require filters/scrubbers or low‑sulfur fuel to enter ports, tax fuel to cover cleanup, restrict docking for non‑compliant vessels.
  • Skeptics point to international waters, flags of convenience, and operators/countries willing to look away; ships might burn dirty fuel offshore and switch to clean only near ports.

Should Cruises Be Banned?

  • Some argue cruises are a “low‑hanging fruit” for climate policy: highly polluting, disease‑prone, labor‑abusive, and purely recreational with hotel‑on‑land alternatives.
  • Others counter this is a slippery slope: many leisure activities are non‑essential and resource‑intensive; singling out cruises reflects personal value judgments.
  • Disagreement over relative impact: one comment cites cruises as ~0.2% of global CO₂, but this thread focuses mainly on SOx, not total climate impact.

Article Framing and Comparisons

  • Multiple commenters call the “10× Europe’s cars” line misleading: European fuels are already ultra‑low sulfur, so car SOx is near zero; the comparison sounds dramatic but may obscure more important sources (overall shipping, coal).
  • Some say the article was previously mocked as a false equivalence; question whether sulfur (vs CO₂) is still the main concern after IMO 2020.
  • Others respond that even if framed sensationally, cruise emissions are still egregious and under‑regulated relative to their social value.

Changes Since 2019 and Alternatives

  • Key change since the article: IMO 2020 sulfur cap; debate continues on its climate side‑effects.
  • Some ports now offer shore power; some lines are adding LNG ships.
  • Emerging alternatives discussed: autonomous solar/wind cargo vessels, rigid‑sail ships, nuclear shipping (noting it’s currently limited to navies).
  • Unclear overall how much Carnival’s sulfur emissions have actually fallen post‑2020; commenters flag this as an open question.