Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB Straubel Stepped Down
Commenters debate whether Tesla has stalled on successful new product launches since former CTO JB Straubel left, noting that the Model 3/Y platform is aging while newer efforts like Cybertruck and Cybercab face design, market-fit, and execution questions. Many argue Tesla’s current valuation rests less on its core EV business—now under heavy pressure from Chinese manufacturers and rivals like Waymo—than on speculative bets such as robotaxis, full self-driving, and the Optimus humanoid robot. There is broad skepticism that these moonshots can scale safely, profitably, and ahead of competitors, especially given Elon Musk’s polarizing public behavior and frequent missed timelines.
Tesla’s Strategic Direction: Cars vs. Robotics/AI
- Many argue Tesla is de‑emphasizing being a car company and pivoting to autonomy, robotaxis (“Cybercab”), and humanoid robots (“Optimus”), possibly as a vertically integrated robotics arm for SpaceX.
- Others say auto manufacturing remains existential: if Tesla can’t prove a manufacturing cost edge using its own robotics/AI, the robotics story itself fails.
- Some see this as rational adaptation to Chinese EV competition and low margins; others call it pure narrative-chasing.
Valuation, Narrative, and “Stock as Product”
- Multiple comments say Tesla’s ~$1T+ valuation can’t be justified by car or battery profits alone, especially vs. Toyota/CATL/BYD.
- Bulls claim the market is pricing in nationwide robotaxis in ~5 years and humanoid robots in ~10.
- Skeptics compare Tesla/SpaceX to Star Citizen or crypto: underlying business matters less than “the next big thing” story.
Competition: Chinese EVs and Waymo
- Consensus that Chinese EV makers (BYD, others) offer strong, cheaper products; many believe they would devastate U.S. automakers if tariffs dropped.
- Some note Tesla’s Model Y is still a top-selling EV in markets like China and AU/NZ, but BYD’s broader lineup outsells Tesla overall.
- On robotaxis, Waymo is widely viewed as far ahead in real, paid rides and operational maturity; others claim Tesla can rapidly overtake via scale if its stack works.
FSD, Robotaxi, and Safety/Liability
- Mixed views on FSD: some say recent versions are finally very good and driving strong subscription growth; others stress it still misses “full self-driving” promises made since 2016.
- Debate over whether autonomy must be merely safer than average humans or will face a far higher social and legal bar, especially around liability for fatal accidents.
- Disagreement on Tesla robotaxi metrics: some cite very low unsupervised ride counts; others highlight rapid ramp-ups in Austin, with conflicting third‑party trackers.
Product Pipeline and Design Choices
- Many agree there’s been no truly new mainstream hit since Model 3/Y; Cybertruck is widely seen as a strategic misfire and “meme truck.”
- Cybercab is criticized as a 2‑seat coupe with awkward doors for taxi use; others say its low cost could be disruptive if autonomy works.
- Some mention Semi, Model Y variants, and Megapack/energy products as genuine but under‑acknowledged successes.
Leadership, Politics, and JB Straubel
- Several commenters argue early success came from strong technical teams while the CEO stayed out of day‑to‑day; they see more direct meddling, politics, and personal issues now.
- Political radicalization is seen by many as having alienated Tesla’s original climate‑conscious customer base.
- The thread is skeptical that one departing executive (Straubel) alone explains post‑2019 product difficulties; COVID, Twitter, and macro factors are cited as confounders.