.name Grandfathered

Verisign has reversed its plan to terminate around 22,000 third‑level .name domains and related email forwarding, opting instead to grandfather all existing registrations while closing off new ones. Commenters see this as a rare win for individual domain holders over a large registry operator, and use the case to probe broader issues of digital property rights, the fragility of relying on centralized DNS, and the financial and technical quirks of niche and “new” TLDs. Many still advise treating non‑core TLDs cautiously, noting past price hikes and governance risks with less common domain extensions.

Outcome of the .name Dispute

  • Verisign has withdrawn its plan to terminate ~22k third-level .name domains and email forwarding.
  • Existing third-level domains and forwarding will continue indefinitely; new third-level registrations will be closed.
  • Commenters see this as the only fair outcome and praise the people who fought it, but remain wary that it was even attempted.

How .name Works and Why It’s Weird

  • .name originally let people register first.last.name as fully separate domains; later, normal second-level domains (lastname.name) were allowed.
  • This creates conflicts between second- and third-level rights and complicates tools like the public suffix list and browser site-isolation / cookie scoping.
  • There is confusion in the thread over whether new third-level registrations are still technically possible; some say only a few registrars still support them, others say registrars have already stopped.

Legal, Ownership, and Consumer Protection Concerns

  • Many argue that terminating long-held domains should be illegal and highlight weak digital ownership laws.
  • Others note that domains are effectively entries in someone else’s ledger, governed by contracts and ICANN rules, not absolute property.
  • Prior case law is cited to show domains can be treated as property, but commenters stress that modern contracts still heavily favor registries/registrars.
  • Annual renewal fees are seen as evidence that registrants are “renters,” enabling brand takeovers and forced transfers.

Economics and Motives

  • Suggested motives for killing third-level .name include:
    • Reducing unique code paths and special services (notably the bundled email forwarding).
    • Making more money from high-value second-level domains (e.g., dictionary or surname .name domains).
  • Some wonder why ICANN doesn’t force Verisign to sell or transfer the TLD if it doesn’t want to maintain it.

Registrar and Transition Problems

  • One large registrar stopped renewing or redeeming third-level .name domains, stranding some users.
  • Advice in the thread:
    • If recently expired, attempt immediate transfer to a registrar that still supports third-level .name and forwarding.
    • If in the redemption period and unredeemable, wait for re-release and re-register.
  • Several users say they migrated email and accounts away from .name preemptively and now feel that effort was wasted, though some welcome the side effect of less spam.

Broader DNS, TLD, and Terminology Debates

  • Many see “new” or niche TLDs as pricing traps; others report stable experiences and argue they can be good for branding.
  • Some prefer sticking to .com/.net; others recommend stable country-code TLDs as safer than generic ones.
  • The incident is cited as evidence that centralized DNS is fragile and that decentralized naming systems are desirable.
  • The term “grandfathered” is criticized due to its Jim Crow origin; alternatives like “legacy” are proposed, while others dismiss this concern.
  • ICANN’s rotating global meeting locations (e.g., Bali) are alternately described as inclusive global practice and as unnecessary travel perks.