We need more goat sacrifices

Social policies and philanthropic programs often fail or backfire, not because problems aren’t real, but because interventions are designed for optics, ideology, or political signaling rather than careful experimentation and feedback. Commenters debate whether examples like school improvement grants, diversity offices, anti-smoking measures, and debt relief show that “nothing works,” or instead highlight the need for better measurement, humility about complex systems, and more honest, iterative trials. The provocative “goat sacrifice” metaphor is used to question who bears the cost of failed interventions and whether policymakers themselves should be forced to have real skin in the game.

Overall reaction to the article

  • Many readers like the writing and humor but find the argument somewhat “bait-and-switch”: heavy emphasis on failed interventions, softer case at the end for “do more experiments.”
  • Some see the piece as implicitly anti-intervention or libertarian; others argue the conclusion is actually “do more, but measure and stay humble.”
  • Several commenters think the examples are cherry-picked and under-analyzed; claims about some programs are called “low quality” or misleading on closer reading.

Signaling, “goat sacrifices,” and theater

  • Strong agreement that many policies and programs function as “goat sacrifices”: symbolic acts meant to show caring or action rather than to work.
  • People compare this to:
    • “Security theater” and “compassion theater.”
    • Diversity offices, social programs, and bureaucracies that mainly perpetuate themselves.
  • Some argue symbolic failure is a feature: if problems persist, politicians can keep campaigning on them.

Measurement, incentives, and Goodhart

  • Broad support for measurable goals and termination clauses, but:
    • Metrics get gamed (Goodhart’s law).
    • Measurement can be costly, distort priorities, and favor what’s easily quantified.
  • Several argue the real missing piece is iterative adjustment, like agile software development, instead of one-shot “waterfall” policies.

Concrete examples and disagreement

  • Tobacco plain packaging:
    • One side says it backfired by pushing smokers to cheaper brands and more consumption.
    • Others cite studies and reviews claiming it accelerated decline in smoking and quit attempts; note mixed but not clearly negative evidence.
  • Other interventions discussed: school improvement grants, diversity officers, medical-debt relief, Afghan women’s programs, Medicaid work requirements.
    • Some see these as evidence that “common-sense” policies often don’t work.
    • Others stress confounders: active sabotage, bad-faith design, or politically constrained implementations.

Complex systems, culture, and ethics

  • Multiple comments highlight:
    • Complex, changing social systems limit the durability and generalizability of findings.
    • Cultural and generational differences can change how interventions land over time.
    • Ethical limits on randomized control in social policy and discomfort with “letting people suffer” for cleaner experiments.

What to do instead

  • Suggestions include:
    • Build explicit falsification and data-collection into policy.
    • Run small-scale pilots, multiple competing interventions, and iterate.
    • Recognize that many programs are primarily political signals, not neutral experiments.