LinkedIn, Monster take down over 1000 fake job postings after CBC investigation

Rampant fake job postings on platforms like LinkedIn and Monster are fueling frustration among job seekers, who report ghost listings, resume harvesting, and roles that are never actually intended to be filled. Commenters link this problem to a broader “scam economy,” arguing that much of the modern internet — from job boards and marketplaces to social platforms — is optimized for ad revenue, data collection, and low-quality offerings rather than genuine services. Many now see personal networks, direct company applications, and independent verification as increasingly necessary to navigate hiring and avoid fraud.

Overall mood

  • Strong sense that scams are pervasive online and increasingly normalized.
  • Many see taking down 1,000 fake job ads as a “drop in the bucket” relative to the problem size.

Fake and ghost job postings

  • Users report:
    • Numerous blatantly fake postings aimed at data harvesting or funneling into MLMs.
    • “Ghost” listings kept open to build resume pipelines or justify internal politics, with no intent to hire.
    • Stale ads left up for years; contacting them yields no response.
  • Some believe a large share of LinkedIn / Monster / Indeed ads are fake or functionally useless.
  • There’s frustration that it took a media investigation, rather than continuous platform controls, to trigger cleanup.

How people actually find jobs

  • Several say job boards have become “worthless”; current advice:
    • Rely on personal networks and direct applications via company sites.
    • Use tools (including AI) to decode vague postings and find the underlying company.
  • Mixed experiences with LinkedIn:
    • Some had multiple past roles via “Apply Now,” but observe current listings feel like resume harvesters.
    • Others never got a single job from LinkedIn in many years.

Bots, AI, and “dead internet” concerns

  • Perception that large parts of job boards and social platforms are bots, AI-generated posts, or coordinated marketing.
  • “Dead Internet” / “evil internet” ideas surface: engagement often not in good faith, designed to manipulate or extract value.

Broader scam and consumer economy

  • Users connect fake jobs to a wider “scam economy”:
    • MLM schemes, crypto/shitcoins, manipulative timeshares, and offshore call-center fraud.
    • Allegations that even big retailers profit from low-quality goods, fake reviews, and search placement optimized for revenue over quality.
  • Debate:
    • One side emphasizes consumer choice and personal responsibility (“people buy cheap junk, so they must want it”).
    • The other stresses systemic manipulation, advertising pressure, and information asymmetry that undermine real agency.

Regulation and incentives

  • Skepticism that platforms or police/fraud units have capacity or incentive to act robustly.
  • Some argue only changed incentives, stronger enforcement, and possibly public/nonprofit alternatives to private marketplaces will help.