Vulcan rocket fails during return-to-flight launch, 40 Amazon satellites lost
United Launch Alliance’s Vulcan rocket suffered a failure on its return-to-flight mission, destroying 40 Amazon Leo internet satellites and raising questions about the reliability of Blue Origin’s BE‑4 engines and the future of Vulcan itself. Commenters highlight how dependent the U.S. has become on SpaceX, noting that competing systems from ULA, Blue Origin, and Rocket Lab are all facing delays or technical setbacks at the same time Amazon is racing regulatory deadlines to deploy thousands of satellites. The incident is seen as both a blow to efforts to maintain multiple viable launch providers and a setback for Amazon’s attempt to challenge SpaceX’s Starlink constellation.
Observed launch behavior & anomaly
- Official stream cut off to PR material without addressing the issue; viewers noted telemetry switching from “Live Data” to “No Data” around +9:24.
- Commenters describe visible rolling of first and second stages around separation, thruster firings to stop roll, and upper-stage engine gimbals moving aggressively, suggesting attitude control challenges.
- The anomaly is said to have occurred about 10 minutes into flight; consensus is that the second stage and payload reentered and burned up rather than reaching orbit.
Speculation on technical cause
- Reports cited in the thread suggest the fault likely originated in the booster stage rather than the Centaur upper stage or solid rocket boosters.
- Several participants note the booster shut down ~40 seconds later than planned, implying underperformance and extra fuel use, leaving the upper stage “lower and slower.”
- There is disagreement whether this clears or implicates the BE‑4 engines; some argue a first-stage underperformance can indirectly doom the second stage, even without a visible BE‑4 explosion.
- Timelines for events are debated, with at least one commenter saying ULA’s posted timeline changed.
Impact on ULA, Blue Origin, and Artemis
- Many see this as a severe blow to ULA, already considered “shaky,” and speculate Vulcan might be retired even if ULA survives via other contracts (Centaur for SLS, Starliner, Amazon).
- If BE‑4 engines are at fault, commenters worry about delays to both Vulcan and Blue Origin’s New Glenn, with knock-on risks for national security launches and Artemis.
- Others note that, regardless of exact cause, either a booster or Centaur issue is bad for key NASA plans that rely on those systems.
Amazon LEO constellation implications
- 40 Amazon LEO satellites were lost. Commenters note Amazon already missed an earlier partial-deployment deadline and now must deploy over 3,200 satellites by mid‑2029.
- There is skepticism Amazon can “catch up” to Starlink at current pace; some suggest they may need more launch providers, but note alternatives (Ariane, Rocket Lab’s Neutron) are delayed or not yet operational.
Launch market concentration & alternatives
- Many stress the need for multiple US launch providers but observe that:
- SpaceX currently carries an overwhelming majority of global launched mass (cited as ~78% this year).
- Falcon 9 is planned for retirement, with no commercial Starship rides yet being sold.
- ULA and Blue Origin are facing anomalies; Rocket Lab’s Electron is too small for big payloads; Neutron is delayed; other US vehicles are not currently operational.
- Some foresee small or emerging players (e.g., Stoke) eventually becoming competitors but doubt they can address near-term heavy-lift/national security needs.
Organizational models, culture, and leadership
- Several comments contrast ULA’s complex, legacy-heavy supply chain and “too many moving parts” with SpaceX’s vertical integration and rapid-iteration culture.
- SpaceX’s model is characterized as building hardware in-house, tight integration between engineering and operations, and willingness to fly test missions with lower-stakes payloads.
- There is a broader discussion about whether enduring high-performance engineering organizations can exist without “cults of personality,” with some arguing visionary leaders are necessary and others pointing to historical programs (e.g., Apollo, Bell Labs, Sun Microsystems) as counterexamples.
Value of mega-constellations and space environment
- Some commenters welcome the loss of 40 satellites as “less space junk,” expressing concern about LEO crowding and invoking Kessler syndrome.
- Others argue that astronomy (especially from ground-based observatories) and radio-quiet sky are harmed by dense constellations.
- There is skepticism about the societal value of thousands of Amazon satellites, contrasted with earlier public-benefit systems like GPS.
“Space is hard” vs. “We already know how”
- One thread disputes the cliché “space is hard,” pointing to dozens of historical orbital launch systems; others respond that repeating established designs is different from developing new, high-performance systems and actually executing them reliably.
- Overall tone acknowledges that modern launch vehicle development remains failure-prone despite decades of experience.