I wish tech companies knew more about me
Online advertising is criticized as both creepily data-hungry and remarkably ineffective at serving useful or relevant content, with many users seeing repeated ads for items they just bought or don’t want, or content in the wrong language or context. Commenters argue this isn’t a lack-of-data problem but an incentive problem: ad systems are optimized to maximize revenue for platforms and advertisers, not to act as genuine recommendation engines for users. Alongside detailed anecdotes about poor targeting and UX missteps, there is broad concern about pervasive tracking, the security risks of adtech, and how collected data is increasingly used to manipulate behavior and shape culture rather than to improve user experience.
Limits of “Better Targeting”
- Many argue that more data wouldn’t make ads feel better: even people who know you well give bad gifts; advertisers ultimately want you to want their product, not the best option overall.
- Several note targeting is structurally constrained by who pays: if Ford bids more than an independent mechanic, you’ll see Ford, regardless of fit.
- Some see a confusion between ads and recommendations: useful, unbiased recommendations would need to be paid by consumers, not vendors.
How Ad Systems Actually Work
- Practitioners say modern ad targeting is heavily ML-based and very complex, with real optimization for click‑through and conversions.
- Others push back that incentives favor “good enough” targeting; ultra-precision isn’t required if impressions are cheap and attribution murky.
- Multiple anecdotes: buying an item triggers a flood of ads for the same or similar items (mattresses, toasters, cars, toilets), which feels obviously dumb but is defended as statistically effective for returns, gifts, or repeat buys.
Effectiveness and Psychological Impact
- Some insist advertising clearly works or it wouldn’t be funded; effects are often long-term brand familiarity, not immediate clicks.
- Others argue much ad spend is wasted or pure “woo,” but still culturally powerful: shaping norms, desires, and feelings of inadequacy.
- A minority report genuinely liking certain well-targeted Instagram/Meta ads that surface niche, unknown products or local events.
UX Failures: Language, Profiles, Recommendations
- Frequent complaints: sites ignoring explicit language settings and forcing geo-based languages; global brands lacking sane locale handling.
- Streaming apps repeatedly ask for profile selection even with one user; some suspect “speed bump” or account-awareness motives.
- Music/video recommendations often ignore obvious negative signals (e.g., always skipping vocal tracks) and get stuck in feedback loops.
Privacy, Surveillance, and Agency
- Strong concern that data collection primarily serves corporate and political manipulation, price discrimination, and risk scoring, not user benefit.
- Some stress that even if you never click, you’re still surveilled; opting out fully would require exiting normal life.
- Others emphasize personal responsibility: ads don’t literally remove agency; not buying is still a choice.
Adblocking and Countermeasures
- Many advocate Pi‑hole, uBlock Origin, DNS-level blocking, especially citing security risks from malicious ad networks.
- Some users prefer irrelevant ads precisely because they’re easier to ignore and less likely to exploit their weaknesses.