Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine
France’s court-ordered DNS blocking of piracy sites, which prompted privacy-focused resolver Quad9 to withdraw services from the country, is seen by many as a step toward a fragmented “splinternet” and state-controlled networks. Commenters argue that using core infrastructure like DNS to enforce copyright and other content laws is technically clumsy, politically dangerous, and ineffective against piracy, while others counter that governments cannot ignore illegal content and will naturally push responsibility up the stack. The broader debate spans fears over censorship, national sovereignty, security, and the erosion of the early, more open internet in favor of tightly regulated, region-specific internets.
Balkanization & Future of the Internet
- Many see Quad9’s withdrawal as part of a long‑running move from a “free global internet” to national or regional “‑nets” (USAnet, EUnet, Runet, Chinanet, etc.).
- Others argue the “free global internet” never really existed; it was always constrained by national sovereignty, export controls, and state firewalls.
- Some predict within 5–7 years the Western internet will be more fragmented, with trade‑like access agreements between blocs and tighter AI control, driven by escalating security crises.
DNS Blocking, Quad9, and Censorship
- Strong concern that forcing DNS resolvers to block sites amputates what makes the internet “inter” and pushes toward a splinternet.
- Quad9 and many commenters see DNS as basic infrastructure (like an address book) that shouldn’t be a copyright enforcement tool.
- Counter‑argument: DNS resolvers do play a small but real role in facilitating illegal activity, so governments naturally move up the chain when hosts are hard to reach.
- Debate over analogies (phone books, roads, knives, bars with drug dealers) reflects disagreement on where responsibility should stop.
Copyright, Piracy, and Business Models
- One camp: if you want to preserve the internet as is, you must offer workable copyright solutions; rightsholders’ concerns, especially over live sports, are politically powerful.
- Opposing camp: current copyright regime is outdated, captured by powerful incumbents, and not worth restructuring the network over; some even advocate abolishing or radically shrinking copyright.
- Several point to streaming’s early success (cheap, convenient) reducing piracy, and blame later price hikes and fragmentation for its resurgence.
- Others stress that piracy will never be zero; copyright enforcement should target sources and business models, not core infrastructure.
Europe, Regulation, and Civil Liberties
- Many criticize the EU and France for “overregulation,” censorship, and building tools that can be reused for broader speech control (chat control, CSAM scanning, Russian media bans, blocking sports piracy).
- Some see this as preemptive lawfare to manage rising social unrest, economic strain, and disinformation; others call that conspiratorial or overstated but agree that hybrid warfare and propaganda changed priorities.
- There is frustration that voters often don’t prioritize “internet freedom,” making political pushback difficult.
Technical & Decentralization Responses
- Suggestions include running personal resolvers (e.g., unbound), greater use of DNSSEC/DoH, alternative networks (Freifunk, Guifi.net), self‑hosting, and P2P/decentralized systems.
- Skeptics note usability, performance, and abuse issues; mass decentralization is seen as hard to achieve beyond technically savvy users.