DNS resolvers are the wrong place to fight piracy
French court orders forcing DNS resolver Quad9 to block piracy-related domains have triggered broader criticism of using DNS infrastructure as a copyright enforcement tool. Commenters argue that targeting resolvers is ineffective, easily circumvented, and creates censorship infrastructure that can later be repurposed beyond piracy, while defenders note courts can compel any intermediary that has the technical ability to block access. The exchange widens into a debate over how (and whether) to fight digital piracy at all, touching on service quality, pricing, jurisdiction, and the long‑term risks of normalizing network‑level content blocking.
AI-Generated Article & Meta Discussion
- Several commenters note the linked piece is AI-written, with mixed reactions.
- Some find AI-generated explainers useful when aggregating scattered info; others view posting such content to HN as irresponsible or low-quality.
- A few argue the article is still informative and well-linked, even if cliché in style.
Nature of the Quad9 Case
- Disagreement over framing:
- One view: this is not “state censorship” but a civil dispute where a rights holder sued Quad9, won, and the court ordered technical measures and damages.
- Counterview: courts are part of the state; enforcing copyright this way is effectively government-backed censorship.
- Important legal detail: Quad9 already blocks malware/ads, showing they can censor domains. Commenters say this undermines any “common carrier” or “we can’t block” defense.
Geo-Blocking vs “Leaving France”
- Confusion over why pure GeoIP blocking was deemed insufficient, yet “leaving France” (no local entity, geoblocking French IPs) is seen as viable risk reduction.
- Explanation offered:
- Geoblocking plus no legal/nexus presence makes enforcement much harder and pushes France into cross-border enforcement via Swiss courts, which may be reluctant.
- Under European/Swiss civil-judgment treaties, enforcement is possible but not guaranteed.
DNS as a Place to Fight Piracy
- Many argue DNS is the wrong layer: it’s just a pointer, easy to bypass (alternate resolvers, DoH/DoT, VPNs, self-hosted resolvers).
- Others counter that any actor in a causal chain who can practically stop illegal activity is a legitimate enforcement target, including DNS resolvers.
- Some point out that ISPs have long blocked piracy at DNS or IP level (e.g., for sports streams), with limited efficacy and substantial collateral damage.
Broader Concerns: Censorship & Infrastructure
- Widespread fear that building DNS/IP blocking infrastructure for copyright will later be reused for political or broader content control.
- Comparisons to blocking messaging apps during unrest and to other EU initiatives seen as privacy- and speech-hostile.
Piracy, Economics & Ethics
- Strong split between:
- “Fight piracy by better, fairly priced, convenient legal services” (Netflix/Steam-style).
- “Piracy is theft; non-enforcement harms creators and pushes harsher controls.”
- Several note streaming fragmentation, high sports pricing, and DRM-laden, revocable “purchases” as major drivers of piracy.