Too many men suffering in silence, national health report finds
A Canadian national report on men’s and boys’ health, highlighting that many are “suffering in silence” and die by suicide at roughly three to four times the rate of women, triggers wide debate over causes and remedies. Commenters point to economic precarity, changing gender roles, stigma around male vulnerability, perceived bias in family law, and social media as major drivers, while disagreeing sharply over the role of feminism and “misandry” in shaping men’s experiences. Others question the quality and framing of the survey itself, arguing that mental health trends are worsening for all genders and that better data, more balanced legal systems, and stronger community support are needed.
Suicide and mental‑health gender gap
- Multiple commenters cite data that women attempt suicide more, but men die by suicide ~3–4x more often, across countries and methods (guns, hanging, trains, poisoning).
- Explanations offered: men’s greater access to lethal means, higher risk‑taking, more “aggressive” methods, and lower help‑seeking.
- Others question how to distinguish “true attempts” from “cries for help,” but note that even “cries for help” reflect serious distress.
- Several see male suicide as intertwined with economic precarity, especially for middle‑aged men.
Causes: economics, culture, and social change
- Strong current that worsening male mental health is driven by economic conditions: unstable work, poor prospects, inability to form or support a family, and housing costs.
- Some argue national reports can’t fix “deep‑seated cultural issues” but can at least establish data and frame future policy.
- Others blame “modernity,” individualism, and the breakdown of local community structures; a few invoke capitalism or “nature correcting” human overgrowth.
Romance, dating, and “surplus men”
- Long subthreads frame male distress through mating markets: more men on dating apps, perceived “surplus” of low‑status men, rising pickiness, and fears of “dying alone.”
- Counter‑arguments: for many, the problem is not zero options but dissatisfaction with available options; self‑confidence, hobbies, and offline socializing are suggested remedies.
- Some reject the surplus‑men narrative as overblown or US‑centric.
Family law, divorce, and gender neutrality
- Many anecdotes of men feeling “ruined” by biased divorce, alimony, and custody outcomes; calls for truly gender‑neutral laws, mandatory prenups, and shared parenting as default.
- Others respond that women are often economically vulnerable due to unpaid caregiving and that law reflects this; they support reform but caution against erasing that reality.
- There’s debate over common‑law marriage, cohabitation rights, and international contrasts (e.g., Brazil, Islamic law).
Perceptions of feminism, masculinity, and misandry
- Some see a “misandric culture” where men are mocked, presumed violent, or dismissed when vulnerable, and claim help for men is resisted as “reactionary.”
- Others strongly push back, criticizing generalized hostility toward women and feminism and arguing that both genders face rising mental‑health problems.
- Recurrent tension over whether men’s problems are distinct “male issues” or manifestations of broader societal decline.
Institutions, therapy, and community solutions
- Mixed views on therapy: some find it transformative; others see it as mis‑targeted, slow, or inaccessible (long waitlists, cost, stigma).
- Suggestions include male‑centered spaces (men’s groups, Scouts, sports, outdoor gyms), religious or spiritual support, and “men supporting men.”
- Several note HR and workplace cultures where men’s issues (e.g., Movember, men’s ERGs) are discouraged or politicized.
Methodology and media skepticism
- The government report itself is criticized as shallow: few vague survey questions, not limited to male respondents, more about perceptions of men than men’s self‑reports.
- Some see the linked article as likely LLM‑generated “AI slop” and prefer primary government sources or human‑written analysis.
- Others argue that even imperfect data can still be a useful starting measurement for public health.
Meta: quality of the discussion
- Multiple commenters describe the thread as one of HN’s “worst,” citing incel‑style rhetoric, gender essentialism, and culture‑war framing.
- Others say these threads predictably attract people with unresolved grievances and that focusing blame on “women” obscures how much harm comes from men’s treatment of other men.